Best RF frequency for the application

bluetoothradioRF

I need to design a device that can transmit an RF signal about 200 meters. The data transferred is very simple. One device simply has a button, that when pressed transmits a two-digit ID to the other unit. There is no other data or voice transmission.

Because the product will be sold globally I'm leaning toward doing 2.4GHz, but I'm concerned about getting the 200 meter range. This range is way outside of most 2.4GHz products. I'm planning on using TI's CC2541 2.4GHz transceiver SoC along with their CC2592 range extender. The CC2592 is supposed to extend the range by up to 7x. BlueGiga sells a Bluetooth Low Energy "Long range" module with a claimed range of 450 meters. So I think reaching 200 meters should be possible.

The other choice is a 868/915/920 MHz system, but that has its own complications, and I would prefer to use a single frequency 2.4 GHz system. Also I'm not sure if 868/915/920 MHz will cover all countries.

So my question is what frequency would you suggest for an international product transmitting a simple ID up to 200 meters?

Thanks!

Best Answer

The 2.4GHz frequency is more solid international standard than 433 MHz. (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISM_band). Any of the carrier frequencies mentioned could transmit to that distance.

Generally, lower frequencies have a better ability to pass through obstacles than the higher frequencies. But, it's almost always a question of the power of the signal. If you don't have the power of the signal, you need to rely of the manufacturers data. Note that generally the transceiver distances are line of sight distances i.e. no obstacles. The obstacles can reduce that distance considerably.

I would recommend a 2.4GHz transceiver with at least double line of sight transecting distance that what you need. TI are good, another option is the Nordic nRF24L01+ chip. Note that it could also be possible with some Bluetooth modules but at that signal strength they are probably illegal!

Good luck, Data source - I'm an EE Engineer.

Related Topic