Confusion about apply nodal analysis

circuit analysis

I'm still new to EE, and taking a introduction class right now. I have a simple question regarding nodal analysis.

Suppose that we have three things connecting in parallel,

  • One 12 voltage source with a resistor in series
  • One resistor by itself
  • One dependent voltage source where its voltage is equal to the voltage across the first resistor

These three are connected in parallel, the negative terminals are connected each other for the voltage sources.

Suppose I want to use node voltage to analyze this circuit.

What I have so far is, choose the node connecting the negative terminals as the reference node, and the node connecting the positive terminals as Node 1.

Then $$I_1+I_2+I_3 = 0$$

But how can I calculate the I_3 when there is only one voltage source there without any resistor?

Best Answer

The verbal description of the circuit sounds like this:

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

Unfortunately, this circuit is unsolvable. VCVS1, configured with gain 1, is asked reproduce the voltage present across R1, while simultaneously being forced to 12V plus the voltage across R1. VCVS1 needs non-unity gain in order for this to be solvable.