Electrical – Do the temperature coefficients of the resistors in the LM399/LM199 “Portable Calibrator” significantly effect the output stability

gainmultimeterprecisionresistorsvoltage-reference

I'd like to know how voltage reference stability is obtained in products like 6.5 digit multimeters that use LM399 as a voltage reference in spite of using two gain resistors. Let's assume an ideal LM399 and ideal op-amp and ideal current source (so ignore the 200k and 5k resistors.) It would seem to me that even at 5ppm, the output would be very sensitive to temperature (relative to a real LM399.) So then how can this work? Is it the case that the resistor temperatures do not fluctuate much because they are near the temperature controlled heater? Or are they measuring the temperature with something like an LM35 (and matched tempcos on the resistors) and calibrating in software?

Even at 5ppm/C and only 0.5C change in temperature (leaving out the trimpot), I'm calculating a range of 10.170 to 10.167 (gain ranging from 1.4634 to 1.4629) which would seem horrible for such an instrument. Do resistors effect gain in the way that I think they do?

I've looked at schematics for a couple such multimeters now and they all use at least two or three discrete resistors and usually aim for an stable output voltage around +/-10V or maybe +/-12V, so is the "Portable Calibrator" a reasonable approximation of a real application?

LM399 portable calibrator

Best Answer

Well if the LM399 has a 0.5 ppm/'C spec 0~75'C that's not good enough for 6.5 digit DMM with 1 ppm accuracy. However the LTZ1000 is 10x better at 0.05 ppm/'C.

It is already thermally heated inside with thermal feedback. Normally better stability can obtained with a double thermal oven servo over the chip just as done in better OCXO's.

Getting laser trimmed Resistor ratios to 1 ppm is a harder task.

Never assume the accuracy is the same as the resolution. Sometimes the extra resolution in the short term is what is needed.

Here is a 7.5 digit meter with 50 ppm accuracy ( only !) enter image description here

Here's a test that compared references enter image description here Keysight 34498A ... innards of a 6.5 digit DMM enter image description here

Keysight's Truevolt 34465A DMM, the 1-year specification applies for temperatures ± 2 °C of the calibration temperature and with self-calibration achieves an accuracy in the 10V range within 24h if 10 ppm of reading and 4ppm of range.

The only other Keysight DMM with ACAL is the high-end 3458A with its high-end price; a bestselling 8.5-digit DMM enter image description here