Electrical – Does voltage and current have an inverse relationship in DC power transmission

dcohms-lawpower

Let's suppose that we want to transmit a 1kW via DC generator with
the below voltage level. From this we can see that the relationship between the DC voltage and current is inversely proportional,

P = I x V

P=1000, V=110, I = ?, then I = 1000/220 = 4.54 amp.
P=1000, V=220, I = ?, then I = 1000/110 = 9.09 amp.

Hence, higher voltage in this case will lead to lower amp.

My issue here, is how can we combine this fact with what we learned in Ohm's law about the current being proportional to the voltage as long as the resistance is constant? As the theories are kind of conflicting in my opinion.

Best Answer

the current being proportional to the voltage as long as the resistance is constant

This is the false premise: If you have a load that consumes constant power irrespective of the voltage, then that load must vary its resistance (higher voltage + higher resistance = same power).

P = I x U

and

R = U / I

both hold at the same time. So there is no way that you can keep the power and the resistance constant when either the voltage or the current or both change.

I.o.w., given R = U / I we can say

I = U / R

P = I x U = (U / R) * U = U² / R, so the power changes when the voltage changes, unless the resistance changes too.