Electrical – Solenoid’s field intensity calculation dependency on width/diameter of coil

coilfieldsolenoid

Textbook formula for field intensity in solenoid coil is

H = (N * I) / l

H magnetic field intensity in ampere-turns

NI ampere-turns

l is length between the coil poles (along the axis of the field flux)

This formula does not take into consideration the width (or diameter) of the coil. Apparently it is based on assumption that diameter is smaller than the length and hence does not significantly impact this calculation.

I am considering a single electromagnet as a model for a BLDC motor' stator coil. Those are often more wider coil diameter and of short coil length.
Wider coil surely weakens the intensity of the field inside the coil. Imagine the flux lines getting thinner as the coil loops get wider. How to reflect this fact in the calculation of the field?
How to adjust that formula to include the width/diameter of the coil?

Also, a bit aside from the main question, please give me a hint How to calculate the attracting force developed in such a wide solenoid in Newtons, knowing field intensity and, say, attracting an iron cylinder of known mass and permeability ?
Note: for the sake of simplicity assume air core in solenoid.

Edit: if my second question seems to spill into larger area of expertise please disregard it and simply suggest the answer to the main question as it is important for finding if the range of the field stays below the saturation point.

Best Answer

You are embarking on a complex problem for which fea was developed. The coil alone will not give an accurate result. The entire magnetic circuit path (loop) must be described. In short; you must find the total iron length, iron area, air gap area and gap-length, an equation describing H vs. B of the iron, and the coil amp-turns. Then compute the total amp-turns drops in the magnetic circuit by starting with an arbitrary value for flux. If NI drop totals are higher than the coil NI, then lower the flux (many iterations may be required). When the true flux value is thus found, compute the air gap energy (the air gap NI x flux/2). Now you must rotate the armature slightly which changes the air gap overlap area and compute it all again. The difference in air gap energy for the two conditions is the energy of rotation (torque x radian angle). Solve for torque.

Related Topic