We have been designing a very high precision control circuit for quite a while. And we are thinking to make it much easier to use, which is to get rid of the Lab DC Sources and use AC to DC switching power (get power from 220V/110V directly).
Our circuit runs at +-12V currently with around 200mA current. It consists of a photodiode, which 1pA precision could be measured, many OpAmps, one 16-bit ADC and one 18 bit DAC. As from the description, it can be observed that our circuit is running at very high precision.
One lab DC source costs thousands of dollars and the DC ripples are basically zero. At most on the level of 0.001mV peak to peak. If a cheap AC to DC source is to be used, however, I am afraid that the DC can be far less clean. For example this one (which has 50mV pp ripples).
I need suggestions from you:
-
Is this kind of AC-DC switching power a good choice (http://www.switchingpowersupply.cc/pdf/D-30W.pdf)? Or maybe the ones used in laptops are better?
-
How to reject the noises in power supply in the most thorough way? Any material will be appreciated.
-
Is it possible to make clean DC source from 220V AC, which has similar performance as the lab DC sources?
-
If large caps and inductance are used to filter the ripples, could they cause stability issues for the AC-DC converters?
-
How would the DC noises influence the behavior of OpAmp, ADC, DAC? For ADC and DAC, I think the voltage references will not be influenced.
Best Answer
Usually if you need clean power, you need to follow up the SMPS with a linear regulator. You also have to deal with the noise created by the supply, which can be non-trivial. If you really need microvolt noise levels, a completely linear supply might be a good choice rather than SMPS, (or even use SLA batteries and an ultra-low-noise regulator).
On the other hand, getting 1mV to 10mV p-p noise over a 0.1Hz to 1MHz bandwidth is not that difficult with a SMPS + LDO combination, but care has to be taken in how the SMPS conducted and capacitively coupled noise is dealt with.
Do not underestimate the noise the supply itself can create- I found that the brick supply for a Tek scope can cause 20mV false spikes in the display if the plastic case is placed near a grounded metal object. That's the supply that the oscilloscope comes with! There are transistors (and possibly entire heat sinks) flapping around by hundreds of volts and switching fast at tens or hundreds of kHz.