Electronic – Contactor vs Relay

contactorrelay

As known, contactor is used to switch higher capacity than relay. But there some relays can switch high current too, such as, some power relays can switch current beyond 100A, and there are contactors to switch only 160A. So, if a relay has a same switching current with a contactor, which one to choose?

And can relays be used in parallel to achieve high switching current to replace a contactor?

Best Answer

Wikipedia's Contactor article explains it pretty well.

Unlike general-purpose relays, contactors are designed to be directly connected to high-current load devices. Relays tend to be of lower capacity and are usually designed for both normally closed and normally open applications. Devices switching more than 15 amperes or in circuits rated more than a few kilowatts are usually called contactors. Apart from optional auxiliary low current contacts, contactors are almost exclusively fitted with normally open ("form A") contacts. Unlike relays, contactors are designed with features to control and suppress the arc produced when interrupting heavy motor currents. [Emphasis mine.]

Further down the same article ...

Differences between a relay and a contactor:

  • Contactors generally are spring loaded to prevent contact welding.
  • Arc-suppression
  • relays usually have NC contacts; contactors usually do not (when de-energerzied, there is no connection).

enter image description here

Magnetic suppression and arc dividers are typically utilized when switching multi-horsepower motors. Magnetic suppression is accomplished by forcing the arc to follow the longer field lines of a fixed magnet placed in close proximity to the contacts. The longer path is specifically designed to force an arc length that can’t be sustained by the availableinductive energies. Figure 3 shows a schematic representation of magnetic arc suppression. Source: Automation Direct, Electrical Arcs - Part 1 of 2 part series.

The article linked above is well worth a read.

Your questions:

So, if a relay has a same switching current with a contactor, which one to choose?

Look carefully at the application and contact rating - particularly for motor or inductive loads. If you are satisfied that either will suffice you can choose based on some other criteria such as cost.

And can relays be used in parallel to achieve high switching current to replace a contactor?

Generally not. While doing this does reduce the long term heating of the individual contacts due to steady current running through them it is a problem during switching due to timing differences. Even wiring contacts of the same relay in parallel is risky as they never are perfectly aligned and the first one to make and last one to break carry the full switching action.