Electronic – Controlling a current with another – home-made alternatives to the transistor

amplifiertransistors

I have a very basic understanding of how a BJT or a FET works, but I think I got the idea. They are awesome in all regards, except one: you can't make one at home without hot ovens and scary chemicals. The old triodes would be easier to make, except they need good vacuum (better than what I could make at home).

Are there any other components that one can use in the place of a transistor or triode, to control a strong current with a weak one?

I thought of these ways – they are naive ideas of someone fascinated but who barely entered the "Novice" stage of electronics:

  • make a weaving of insulated copper wire (like a tight grid) and pass other wires through the eyes of the weaving, so a voltage in the weaving (the controller) could scare off the electrons going through the passing wires (the controlled) using its electric field, like how the grid works in a triode, or how the gate works in a FET

  • put a plate (controller) between the plates of a capacitor (controlled), so when you put a current through the controller-plate, the capacitor's capacity is modified a bit so its reactance changes (I haven't given much thought to this idea, nor to how could it be used, it will definitely sound stupid)

  • put a cylindrical capacitor (the controller) around a wire (the controlled), so the negative, inner cylinder will be close around the wire; hopefully, charging the capacitor will … oh wait… the net electric field outside a capacitor is supposed to be 0…

I already assume these ideas are wrong in innumerable ways. Could you please point out some of the mistakes? I hope I'll learn a lot this way.

Transistors and triodes are the best, most convenient, quickest and most efficient for this task. I know it very well, I don't deny it in any way. This question is asked in the spirit of "What I cannot create, I do not understand." and "Know how to solve every problem that has been solved.", as Feynman so brilliantly put it.

I'm primarly interested in control as in amplification with a gain. Switching on/off isn't really enough – I think I'd like to use this thing in an oscillator or RF circuit.

Best Answer

There is the magnetic amplifier. I think that it looks pretty easy to build, and works rather well.

Here's a good book about mag amps: Magnetic Amplifiers, Paul Mali, 1960, 101 pages, found in Pete Millet's truly awesome book collection. From this book:

Simple Saturable Reactor. Source: Magnetic Amplifiers, Paul Mali, 1960

"Basically, the principle of the simple saturable reactor can be stated in two parts: As magnetic core saturates, current to load increases; as magnetic core desaturates, current to load decreases." (p.28)

Another picture illustrates this:

Magnetic Amplifier Input vs. Output Waveforms. Source: Magnetic Amplifiers, Paul Mali, 1960

When you vary the DC current (control circuit), you drive the core into or out of saturation, controlling the slope if the output-to-input transfer characteristic (AC load circuit).

Note that because the underlying principle is an inductor, you can control AC load currents only. For DC applications, it is possible to control an AC current and rectify the output, using a diode rectifier and a smoothing capacitor.

Besides the rather exotic applications in early military technology, avionics or high voltage transmission, there are at least two examples where saturable inductors were used by the millions in consumer devices:

  • Post-regulation in switch-mode power supplies - actually an applicaton where an AC current is controlled to create, after being rectified, a stabilized DC voltage.

  • Circuits for correcting the otherwise distorted geometry ("cushion shape") of a picture on a CRT display. Here, the AC current to the picture tube's deflection coils is modified by a controlled saturable inductor.