First you say you have ONE twisted pair, and then you say "one of the twisted pairs". We will assume that you really have only ONE pair and you meant to say "one of the wires of the twisted pair".
You are correct that unless you have rather low-frequency signals and a quite short (perhaps 1m) cable, you will likely experience bad to severe "crosstalk" between the two signals because they are so effectively capacitively coupled together by the twisted geometry.
There are ways of sending two different signals over a pair including time-domain and frequency-domain multiplexing. And using a Phantom Circuit.
OK so the key is in your question, COMMON MODE NOISE...
Consider the following image..
Without twisted pair the line closest to the noise source gets more noise than the other line. So the noise is no longer common mode.
By twisting the wires you negate, or significantly reduce this effect.
Telephone systems are, or were, all transformer based, which is effectively differential.
So what of single ended..
Well arguably, there is no such thing. You are always passing the difference between something... but I won't open that can of worms...
In a simple system, you are not only passing the signal but also passing a reference point... usually we call it ground.. Again. if there is more noise in the signal line than the ground line, that gets picked up by your receiver.
Of course, that all goes out the window if there is some other ground paths or the grounds are shared with other signals.
Ultimately, it depends on the application. If it's single ended... where there are only two wires connecting between each device, and the receiver is battery operated or powered from the communication line, twisted pair helps a lot. If there are multiple connections or both the transmitter and receiver signal grounds are grounded locally to the mains... not so much.
In fact, in some instances over-use of twisted pairs can make things worse...
For example, running single ended signals through twisted pair ribbon cable is generally a bad idea.
The fact that you are bringing your signal wire closer to the neighboring signal wires increase the cross coupling between them. It is better to use a standard flat ribbon cable with ground wires between each signal acting as a kind of shielding.
Best Answer
They don't is the short and long answer. However, if you are wanting to fully utilize the space on your PCB for other components and other non-connected circuits you need to use ground planes to avoid upsetting the controlled impedance and avoiding unnecessary cross-talk or interference.