Electronic – Is this alternative relay flyback diode path good enough

flybackrelay

This question is about an alternative path for relay flyback diodes.

I plan to drive panasonic 12VDC CP1-12V relay with a NUD3160LT1G power MOSFET and the NUD3160LT1G datasheet says because the MOSFET comes has protection diodes, there is no need for a "free−wheeling diode" to drive an inductive load.

My question is, is it good enough to have this topology of flyback path through high voltage zener diodes and ground and +12 ground rails or should I connect a reverse diode directly on the relay's coil anyway.

This is for a non critical one-of audio application in my car. Cost is not an issue but I would prefer avoiding an additional diode if possible. The NUD3160LT1G will be driven by a 5V ATMEGA328P MCU if it maters.

enter image description here

Best Answer

This is good the zener from the drain to gate turns on when Vds starts to rise due to the inductive load when the fet turns off. This partially turns the fet back on dissipating the inductive spike in the fet safely. This is a recognized method of flyback protection.