Electronic – Modelling a capacitor whose dielectric has resistance as a circuit element

capacitorcircuit-designresistance

Modelling a capacitor whose dielectric has resistance as a circuit element @ Physics Stackexchange


The issue of 'how to model the capacitor' arises if the dielectric of a parallel plate capacitor has a finite resistance.

enter image description here

As the diagram indicates, current can flow through the capacitor. However, this does not mean that the capacitor acts as a closed circuit. The $r$ is quite large and allows very little current through the dielectric. The current through the dielectric won't enough to prevent a charge build up on the plates. Therefore, the capacitor does not lose its capacitor related properties.

Idea #1 (capacitor with resistance = ideal capacitor and ideal resistor in series):

It might seem intuitive to pull the resistor out of the capacitor and assume that they function as an ideal capacitor and an ideal resistor separately.

enter image description here

This model will immediately run into problems because:

  1. If you use a DC source, after very long time, the potential drop across the capacitor will be equal to the E.M.F of the source. This would prevent any current from flowing. The potential difference across the capacitor is caused by the charge separation. However, as the dielectric can conduct electricity, the charge on the plates could move. This would never allow the potential difference across the capacitor to be equal to the E.M.F of the source.

Therefore, this model will fail.

Idea #2 (capacitor with resistance = ideal capacitor and ideal resistor in parallel):

After trying Idea #1, the next attempt would be to analyze if considering the dielectric resistance to function as a resistor in parallel.

enter image description here

This idea has the following problems:

  1. After a sufficiently long time, there would be a constant current in the circuit as the capacitor behaves like an open circuit. There won't be any current passing through the capacitor branch. But with the original capacitor, the charges on the plates of the capacitor can flow through the capacitor. So you cannot have a constant potential difference across the capacitor.

How do you model a capacitor which has a finite resistance?

Would I need to go scrap all the capacitance and resistance concepts and start from the fundamentals?

Best Answer

It seems you are asking how to more simply model a capacitor with "leaky" dielectric. The answer is a ideal capacitor with a resistor in parallel.

Charge up the capacitor to a fixed voltage and wait. The real capacitor will discharge slowly because of the finite resistance of the dielectric. The simplified model exhibits the same discharge due to the resistance across the ideal capacitor.

With a steady voltage applied externally, both also result in the same current, which is the voltage divided by the leakage resistance.

In general, the first order approximation of a capacitor is simply a ideal capacitor. For many uses of real capacitors, this is good enough.

The second approximation has a resistor both in series with a ideal capacitor, and one in parallel with it. The series resistance is referred to as the ESR (equivalent series resistance). This can matter in real circuits, especially when the cap is subjected to high currents.

The parallel resistance models the leakage inherent in the dielectric. This is so little (resistance so high) in ceramic capacitors that it can usually be ignored. However, leakage is more significant in other types, like electrolytic, and must be taken into account in some applications.

Note that both the equivalent series and leakage resistances can vary significantly over temperature. The leakage of electrolytic caps in particular go up significantly with higher temperature.

Of course these are all models with different tradeoffs between simplicity and fidelity. You can get really anal and make a model of a capacitor that takes into account all kinds of third order effects, like series inductance, distributed capacitance between the series inductors, between the multiple distributed series and parallel resistances, their inductance, etc, etc, etc. The more you keep going, the more you model the true behavior of any one capacitor, but the less practical the model is for designing circuits.