Electronic – Peak power pulse in parallel MOSFETs

mosfetpower-dissipationswitching

I have a circuit like the one shown below. To make the schematic easier to read, I only show 2 FETs in parallel. I actually have 8 identical FETs in parallel. The HT0440 is a high-side N-channel FET driver. It's controlled by a digital signal from an MCU.

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

Power is not switched on and off rapidly in this application, but I am still concerned about the instantaneous heating in the FETs when power is turned off. Particularly when RLoad is small and the current is high prior to being switched off. I probed the source pins of the FETs during a switch-off event and observed this curve:

enter image description here

It takes about 250ms for the FETs to fully turn off. RLoad in this case was 10 Ohm. I did some calculations in a spreadsheet and came up with this curve for power-vs-time in the MOSFETs during the switch-off event:

enter image description here

Integrating under the curve, I get about 17Ws (Watt-seconds). That's the total accumulated power loss among all 8 MOSFETs. There's a graph in the MOSFET's datasheet that shows the maximum single pulse power dissipation as a function of pulse width.

enter image description here

Now, I know that MOSFETs in parallel will work "nicely" with each other to share the total current because of their PTC nature. However, I don't know if it's safe to assume they will continue to work nicely together during a switch-off event. In other words, as the gate pins are being driven low, is there some property of MOSFETs that would cause one single MOSFET to end up taking the brunt of the switching power dissipation? Or will they all share the total power dissipation equally?

Best Answer

In other words, as the gate pins are being driven low, is there some property of MOSFETs that would cause one single MOSFET to end up taking the brunt of the switching power dissipation? Or will they all share the total power dissipation equally?

Your suspicions are correct. The normally nice side of MOSFETs sharing current only applies when the gate source voltage is above a certain threshold called the zero-temperature-coefficient (ZTC) threshold. For the MOSFET you have chosen it is about 6.7 volts: -

enter image description here

Basically I took figure 5 and extended the curves to the ZTC threshold. At gate voltages lower than this a MOSFET will warm to destruction if not prevented in some way. Take for example the situation at 25 degC and the instant application of a gate voltage of 5 volts. Current will be about 40 amps and this will cause the junction temperature to rise rapidly and, within a few milli seconds it will have warmed to 150 degC and now will be taking about 140 amps. The junction will rapidly rise past the 175 degC limit and reach destruction temperature (about 650 degC) in a few more milliseconds.

Not all of the silicon die will warm this way. In modern HEXFETs there are a gazillion parallel small MOSFETs and the most vulnerable are those closest to the centre and farthest away from the "cooler" edge. You wil get hot-spotting and the central 10% of the die will take all this current and destruct unless there are limits to the current flow.

This can happen in less than 10 ms and you wouldn't even notice hardly the slightest external change in temperature on the case. In other words, heat sinks DO NOT prevent this happening.

So hot-spotting can happen in a group of MOSFETs and it can also happen in an individual MOSFET. Some MOSFETs are designed for operating in this area and IXYS make quite a few. The front page of the data sheet will tell you. If it says that the MOSFET is for switching applications then it is likely to be vulnerable; if it says it is for linear applications than it is likely suitable and, if you look at a suitable device's equivalent of figure 5 you will see that the curves are much tighter leading to very little extra drain current as the device warms.

Go google "thermal instability in MOSFETs" and please consider a MOSFET driver that can turn off the gate voltage in less than 1 ms. Those MOSFETs have a gate-source capacitance of 15 nF and 8 of them makes a total capacitance of over 100 nF. It may even be necessary to use several gate drivers.