Electronic – Physically, how does connecting a PCB to chassis ground reduce noise

groundnoise

I realize this may seem to duplicate Should chassis ground be attached to digital ground? but the answers in that thread don't explain why one should connect the chassis to PCB ground, aside from obvious safety concerns which I understand.

My logic is this: if I have a PCB with sensitive analog circuitry, I should put it in a metal chassis and keep it insulated from my PCB. The chassis acts as a faraday cage, which keeps my PCB from outside EM noise, and also keeps noise from emanating from my (say) RF PCB. I see no reason to connect the two, if safety is not a concern. draeth's answer in the aforementioned link seems to agree with this.

However, conventional wisdom from very knowledgeable people says a low impedance path to the metal chassis should be established to reduce noise and EMI.

Why should this be done? It seems like by connecting my ground to the chassis, one would expose their circuit to noise from the outside. And as well expose the outside to noise!

Best Answer

This going to be another controversial question, so let me paraphrase and occasionally quote from a source (textbook) that I find credible, EMC and the Printed Circuit Board by Mark Montrose. First, let's intro the usual terminology:

  • safety ground = a ground that is connected by a low-impedance path to earth
  • signal voltage (referencing) ground, e.g. ground plane on a PCB

Now a potentially shocking quote (p. 249):

Connection of the two ground methods may be unsuitable for a particular application and may exacerbate EMC problems. [...] Common misconceptions exist regarding grounding. Most analysts believe that ground is a current return path that a good ground reduces circuit noise. This belief causes many to assume that we can sink noisy RF current into the earth, generally through a building's main grounding structure. This valid if we are discussion safety grounding, not signal voltage reference. Although an RF return path is mandatory, it need not be at ground potential. Free space is not at ground potential.

(Emphasis mine).

So having established that (if it needed to be said), what about connecting a PCB (or in case of a multi-board device, several PCBs') ground to the metal case/chassis even if the latter is not connected to the earth/safety ground? (You could have a Faraday cage housed in a plastic enclosure for example.)

First we need to get something else cleared: if you have a multi-board system, single-point grounding (aka "holy" ground, no kidding) is suitable when the speed of signals/components is 1 Mhz or less, usually found in audio circuits, mains power systems, etc. For higher operating frequencies, e.g. a computer, multi-point grounding is used. For mixed frequencies both are combined in a hybrid grounding technique as shown below (figure from Montrose's book):

enter image description here

And here's basically why you want multi-point grounding for high-frequency systems, which in Montrose's book (p. 274) is explained in the context of a system with daughterboards (e.g. your typical desktop computer):

RF fields generated from a PCB [...] will couple to a metallic structure. As a result, RF eddy currents will develop in the structure and will circulate within the unit creating a field distribution. This field distribution may couple to other circuits [...] These [eddy] currents are coupled to the card cage through distributive transfer impedances and then through attempts to close the loop by coupling back to the backplane. If the common-mode reference impedance between the backplane and the card cage is not significantly lower than the distributive "driving source" (of the eddy currents) an RF voltage will be developed between the backplane and the card cage. [...] Simply put, the common-mode spectral potential between the backplane and card cage must be shorted out. This may take the form of frequently connecting the backplane ground plane to the card cage (chassis) at regular intervals around the perimeter of the backplane.

If you wondered why your desktop computer motherboard has electrical connections through all the screws that fasten it to the (metallic) case, that's why they're there.

N.B.: Joffe and Lock's Grounds for Grounding gives pretty much the same explanation in their section titled "Purpose of Stitching PCB Return Planes to Chassis", so I think the experts agree on this.