Electronic – Resonant frequency of RLC circuit

circuit analysisfrequencyimpedanceresonance

Analysis

I'm trying to find the resonant frequency for this circuit

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

Writing up the node voltage equation for \$V_o \$
$$\frac{V_o-V_{in}}{Z_L}+\frac{V_o}{Z_C} + \frac{V_o}{R}=0 $$
And using that \$\frac{V_o-V_{in}}{Z_L}= \frac{1}{L} \cdot \displaystyle\int (V_o-V_{in} )\: dt \$ and \$\frac{V_o}{Z_C}=C \cdot \frac{dV_o}{dt} \$ brings us
$$C \cdot \frac{dV_o}{dt} + \frac{1}{L} \cdot \displaystyle\int (V_o-V_{in} )\: dt + \frac{V_o}{R}=0$$
Dividing through with \$C \$, differentiating every term and moving \$V_{in} \$ to the right hand side gives me
$$\frac{d^2V_o}{dt}+ \frac{1}{RC} \frac{dV_o}{dt} + \frac{1}{LC}V_o = \frac{1}{LC} V_{in}$$

Calculations

According to "Eletrical Engineering principles and applications by Hambley", the square root of the term before \$V_o \$ is called the undamped resonant frequency \$\omega_0 \$.

In this case the resonant frequency is
$$\omega_0 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{LC}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{62 \text{uH} \cdot 63 \text{nF}}} = 0.5059 \: \text{MHz}$$
Also according to Hambley, at the resonance frequency the equivalent circuit impedance is purely resistive, so \$\Im{(Z_{eq})} = 0 \$.

The equivalent impedance of this circuit is
$$Z_{eq} = Z_L + \frac{R \cdot Z_C}{R + Z_C} = sL + \frac{R}{sC(R+ \frac{1}{sC})}$$
Plugging \$s= j\omega_0 \$ and plugging in component value into the above equation gives me
$$Z_{eq} = 15.14 + j11.57 \Omega$$

Question

Which clearly shows that the impedance isn't purely resistive. So my question is, why not? Is my equivalent impedance wrong, or perhaps my resonance frequency?

Edit

Source about resonant frequency

enter image description here

Figure 6.23

enter image description here

Best Answer

I'm trying to find the resonant frequency for this circuit

Try this calculator. I spent a lot of time getting it right LOL: -

enter image description here

The natural resonant frequency you calculated is in radians per second by the way. In hertz it is 80.52932 kHz.

Also according to Hambley, at the resonance frequency the equivalent circuit impedance is purely resistive

That isn't true from what I can tell.... If you look at this impedance matching calculator on the same basic website it shows at what frequency the input will be purely resistive: -

enter image description here

I've had to frig around to make the numbers match about right with the first calculator but, the upshot of what it is telling you is that the frequency where the input impedance is purely resistive is 50.63 kHz. And, at that frequency, the input resistance is 24.79 Ω.

There are full derivations on that page.