Electronic – Stiff Voltage Divider Bias for an Emitter Follower

emitter-followerthevenintransistorsvoltage divider

Below is an ac-coupled emitter follower with base bias provided by a voltage divider. I'm having a slight issue with how the resistor values are chosen for the biasing in the design example provided in the Art of Electronics (pg 70). I've included the design steps given in the book up to that point.

enter image description here

Step 1. Choose VE. For the largest possible symmetrical swing without
clipping, VE =
0.5Vcc, or +7.5 volts.
Step 2. Choose RE. For a quiescent current of 1mA, R E = 7.5k.
Step 3. Choose Rl and R 2 . VB is VE+
0.6, or 8.1 volts. This determines the ratio of Rl to R 2 as 1: 1.17. The preceding loading criterion requires that the parallel
resistance of Rl and R 2 be about 75k or less (one-tenth of 7.5k
times h FE ). Suitable standard values are R 1 = 130k, R2 = 150k.

In step three, it says the Thevenin equivalent of the voltage divider used (R1//R2) should be at least ten times less than the apparent resistance of the load resistor RE (RE * hFE). However, I think that instead of the Thevenin equivalent, we should only consider R2, since R2 is effectively in parallel with the load resistance * hFE. If we don't, then won't the loading effect on the voltage divider be too great?

Best Answer

Looking into the base terminal we see the equivalent of a resistor of value Re *hfe, so if hfe is 200, it looks like a 1.5M resistor to ground.

They are saying we can ignore that if R1 || R2 << (Re * hfe), where they consider an order of magnitude to be close enough- so a reduction in swing of Vcc/20 is considered insignificant. There's nothing stopping you from correcting the ratio a bit to account for typical hfe, but when AoE was written 5% resistors were much cheaper than 1% and it didn't matter that much.