Electronic – Which is more efficient over 300 to 500 miles high voltage AC or high voltage DC

acdcpowertransmission line

BEFORE you jump to answer or flag as duplicate read please read this first! I always assumed like yourself that AC would be more efficient and in part that is what Tesla and Edison fought over to reconcile and AC won and the rest is history….enter. "Scientific American" page 20 June 2017. Article titled " Electric Renaissance" by Annie Sneed. says

" Technology for power transmission advanced in the 1970's, allowing direct current to return as a viable option-and for lines more than 300 to 500 miles long, DC out competes AC.After a certain distance , AC systems become more costly to build than DC and have larger power losses along the line because of issues such as higher resistance. " Using DC lines is a much better solution for moving power from big, remote wind or solar farms",says Gregory Reed, director of the University of Pittsburgh's Center for Energy and Energy GRID Institute…."

I always thought DC sources were converted to alternating current for efficiency sake not to just accommodate the AC infrastructure that is all ready in place. Obviously you have to step down the AC before it is allowed to get in side the house but isn't the reason DC was never used to begin with was because of the resistance in DC power transmission and that the lines would have to be as thick as a telephone pole not to mention you need a power source at every corner. Can some one clear my obvious confusion. Thank you again!

Best Answer

HVDC is more efficient over such distance. Here are the reasons:

There is no inductive/capacitive reactance in the case of DC whereas in case of AC both capacitive/inductive reatances exist. Due to the absence of Inductance, the voltage drop in HVDC is very small as compared to AC (Provided that all other conditions are constant). Due to this reasons, the HVDC provides an edge over the voltage regulation of power system.

HVDC is free from dielectric losses. Also, there is no skin effect of conductor and whole conductors is utilised for power transmission.

In terms of cost of power system DC is more efficient and is least expensive. Firstly we only require two conductors instead of three. But the only problem we suffer is a generation of power at high voltages because we need HV for transmission. DC can neither be stepped up directly and neither can it be generated at very high voltages. So at present, the only solution is to use Solid state electronics and convert HVAC to HVDC for transmission purposes, then again convert it back to AC and step down for transmission purposes.