Electronic – Why are charge pumps only used for low current applications

capacitorcharge-pumpinductorpower supplyswitch-mode-power-supply

Typically the most expensive (and hard to get) elements in a SMPS are the inductors. Thus I was wondering if it's possible to use inductor-less switching mode power supplies (i.e. charge pumps) for generic use cases, for example a bench-top power supply, fixed high power DC-DC converters (several amperes and some hundred watts power), etc.

All charge pump designs I could find though were for low power applications. What prevents one from designing a high power inductor-less power supply? Are there some inherent physical limitations?

Best Answer

There are two problems with your idea. One practical, and one fundamental.

The practical problem is that per amount of stored energy capacitors are more expensive than inductors, and on top of that the realy high-capacity capacitors (electrolytic) age.

The fundamental problem is that charging a capacitor from a voltage source is fundamentally lossy (you dissipate heat). This might seem counter-intuitive, but is nonetheless true. (There was a question about this some time ago.) Hence a flying-capacitor voltage converter, even an ideal one, is inherently inefficient. (An ideal inductor-based voltage converter is 100% efficient.)

You might think it strange that the world is unfair to capacitors, but that is our human fault: we supply power mostly from voltage sources. For current sources the inverse is true: an ideal current converter from flying capacitors can be 100% efficient, while one from inductors must necessarily be lossy.