Electronic – Why can’t CMOS simply be made of n-type enhancement mode MOSFETs and n-type depletion mode MOSFETs

cmosdigital-logiclogic-gatestransistors

According to my textbook, a CMOS must use both PMOS and NMOS transistors because a CMOS needs transistors that follow the positive logic system and transistors that don't follow the positive logic system. n-type enhancement mode MOSFETs do follow the positive logic system and n-type depletion mode MOSFETs don't follow the positive logic system, so why can't only NMOS transistors be used?

The positive logic system defines 0 (off) as low voltage and 1 (on) as high voltage.

Best Answer

That's been done already. It's called "Depletion-load NMOS", as opposed to "CMOS" with the "C" meaning "complementary", i.e. both NMOSFETs and PMOSFETs.

The primary disadvantages of NMOS are(were):

  1. Its power dissipation is higher than CMOS since the pullups never turn off (versus PMOSFETs).
  2. Drive strength is asymmetrical due to high-side pullups versus low-side switches.