I have an electrical engineering degree, but little experience in building wireless equipment. I need to transmit a signal through about 100 feet of distance, including a concrete wall. I need something small that will transmit just a binary "I'm ON" signal when on, and nothing when off.
I don't really care how large the receiver is, but I'd like the transmitter to be relatively small. The transmitter would really only get a "power on" signal–be expected to transmit when it has power–and then stop transmitting when the power ceased.
Ordinarily for this application I would use some kind of large overkill solution just to use familiar off-the-shelf components. But very little seems to make it into this concrete enclosure (Cell/WiFi/GPS/etc.) What might I use?
Best Answer
You have to be careful with this kind of 'I'm on' signal.
A lot of regulations for un-licensed radio frequencies (such as the ISM band, etc) stipulate a maximum duty cycle on the transmission, meaning that you are only allowed to actively transmit for a certain % of the time. This prevents blocking of a particular frequency and allows better TDM of signals.
For example, for the ISM (Industrial, Scientific, Medical) range:
So whatever solution you go for you will have to create some kind of periodic pulsed beacon that sends a short burst signal at pre-defined periods rather than just a constant 'on' signal.
This should also mean that you can save power in between the pulses as you can turn the transmitter off (a lot of TX chips have a 'sleep' or 'shutdown' mode) when it's not actively being used.
As has been mentioned in some of the comments, there is most likely a set of reinforcement bars in the concrete forming a 'Faraday cage'. This blocks a large number of signals from penetrating as they hit the bars and then get grounded by them. So, you need to pick a frequency that has a wavelength that is smaller than the space between the bars. Also, concrete can absorb the signal at certain frequencies.
From what I understand this is mostly due to the water content in the concrete. Water contains hydrogen. Hydrogen resonates at 2.4GHz. Many transmissions (WiFi for example) occur at 2.4GHz, so the hydrogen in the water in the concrete absorbs the transmission.*
So, the ISM 868MHz band has a wavelength of about 0.35m - this is probably going to be way too big to fit between the bars (I'm not sure what the regulations state about bar spacing). ISM 915 takes it down to 0.33m - still too big. The 2.4GHz is 0.125m - much more realistic but may not get through the concrete. So you'd be looking somewhere in the mid-to-high 1GHz range. Personally I'm not aware of a license free frequency range in that area. You'd need to check with the RF licensing people in your area (FCC, OfCom, etc).
*(This is purely my own conjecture - please correct me as I'd like to know the truth myself)