Diodes – Diode-Connected BJT vs Base-Emitter BJT Diode vs Diode

analogbjtcurrent-mirrordiode-clampdiodes

I was having a look at the circuit design of Keithley 236 SMU. You can find this part of the circuit in the Keithley 236 Service Manual.

Circuit Diagram

Q47 is a BJT. Only the base and emitter are connected, which means it is used as a diode.

I also made a simulation to compare these three variations, which seems not a lot of difference. (Pink is voltage, blue is current)
Simulation

My questions are:

  • Is it better to use diode-connected BJT to enhance its flowing current without affecting too much the forward voltage in this circuit?
  • Are there any particular reasons against using a normal diode or a diode-connected BJT in the original design?
  • What are the differences among those three kinds of diodes (i.e. diode-connected BJT vs base-emitter BJT diode vs diode)? (I know there is an answer about diode-connected BJT and diode here.)
  • In this design, all these three "diodes" are used. How could I determine which one to use in the design?

My initial guess is the cost and part availability but I would like to know if there is any design consideration about this.

Edit – This is where diode-connected BJTs are used in this design.

additional schematic

Best Answer

I suspect, without knowing the specs, that the criteria is for this design is bandwidth of the ideal rectifier (with Op-Amp negative feedback) for the transistor characteristics selected in the Vbe(f) vs Ibe(f).

The Ideality Factor =1 for which the active diode is best for lowest Rce due to current gain in a common size is commonly used for DC current mirrors.

  • schottky diodes might be lower junction capacitance but much higher bulk resistance. CMOS input protection must be faster than then FETs so they are made extremely small and thus only rated for 5mA DC current. This might also be suitable.
  • Silicon diodes might also be a higher RC breakpoint, yet the

But it is the BW of the rectifier for which a transistor is chosen with low Cbe(low pF) in the BE junction , it will perform better in a spectral sweep , carrier rectifier than a small signal diode.

The fact is that diode capacitance increases with size and current ratings at V=0 and bulk resistance Or incremental saturation R also reduces with increased current rating.

Without knowing which diode and transistor characteristics were used, the forward voltage is irrelevant as the Op-Amp loop gain can null the input error.

So my opinion is they selected this for the frequency response of a low cost transistor, rather than a more expensive PIN diode.

This answer might be improved if then application specs were given.