Electrical – Why is the load on a darlington pair put before the transistors rather than after

darlingtontransistors

Forgive my lack of understanding and if this is answered somewhere I have not found, but…
I have seen lots of answers with regard to how to use a darlington pair to switch, say, a 12V 1A load using a 3.3V 50mA signal (just an example, not all values are determined for my application,) but what I'm not clear on is why in the solutions using a darlington pair, the load is always placed on the high side of the transistor(s). While switching the low side is common and functionally fine, in my application, for safety reasons, I would prefer to switch the high side of the load.
So, is it ok to put the load on the output of a Darlington Pair Transistor?

Best Answer

It depends on how well the darlington transistor is heatsinked, and whether its extra voltage drop matters.

When a darlington pair is used with a collector load, the voltage drop is around 1v, that's a VBE of around 0.7v for the first transistor, and a VCEsat for the second.

When a darlington pair is used with an emitter load, the voltage drop is in the range of 1.5v, a VBE for each transistor, and often a bit more depending on how hard they need to be driven. That's assuming the base voltage can be taken all the way to the positive rail. If it can't, and all devices need some drop across them to source current, then that adds directly extra voltage drop to the output. Increased voltage drop means not only lower load voltage, but also increased darlington heating.

There are PNP darlingtons available, so that you can do positive side switching with the load in the collector.