Electronic – 240V 5A PCB traces – stitch double sided or not

currentheatpcb-design

If I have traces connecting a relay to an terminal block (10A relay, 6A terminal, 5A expected maximum load) and I double the traces up on both sides of the board (mirror the traces on the top and the bottom) to double the current capacity of the traces (effectively turn 1oz copper into 2oz), is it best to leave them as they are or to stitch the traces together with vias?

The longest trace is just under 1".

Would the stitching adversely affect the current capacity of the traces and defeat the objective? Or would it allow for better heat management and thus actually increase the current capacity?

Or would it have no effect whatsoever?

And what of the effect of 50/60Hz through the two traces with FR4 dielectric between them? Would doubling, with or without stitching, have an effect?

Best Answer

Stitching (with vias I assume) will increase your cost. According to PCB trace calculator, for a 1oz copper and 5A load you need a trace about 3mm wide (for 10C warming over ambient). Can you afford this? If not, the standard trick is to beef up the trace with solder build-up, as manufactures do in millions of PC power supplies.

Stitching, however, will slightly improve thermal management of the trace, since vias will increase the heat exchange between two traces in cases of bad board orientation relative to gravity direction, when one side has a depressed air convection relative to the other side.

Related Topic