Electronic – 5V Regulator Power Dissipation

5vheatsinkpower-dissipationsurface-mountvoltage-regulator

I am using a 5V regulator (LP2950) from ON Semiconductor. I am using this for USB power and I'm feeding in 9V from an adapter. USB requires maximum of 500mA right? So the maximum power dissipation in the regulator is (9V – 5V) * 500mA = 2W. My Question is whether this regulator can take that much power with 10x10mm copper as heatsink on the PCB?

Also I was looking at another regulator (LM2940S-5.0/NOPB) from TI. Which one would you thing would be a better regulator to use with the same 10x10mm copper area as heatsink. Remember I am using this to power up a USB port (not on the computer side because that provides 5V, 500mA)

Best Answer

few points:

the datasheet says part is internally current limited and thermally current limited, but no information is given regarding the limits, generally they will give Thermal trip point and Internal current limit at particular condition.

the maximum current given by LDO will depend upon the series elements current handling capacity also. basically we need to do thermal analysis.

Worst case Power dissipated across = VinminIoutmax-(VoutmaxIoutmax)-PQ(Quiscent Power). So, here if Vinmin to Voutmax difference reaching to min dropout voltage, we can have maximum current which will not exceed the Tj of the device package.

from datasheet, in section Electrical characterstics, Ilimit(Vout shrted to GND) is 300mA.

from Ruff calc, by neglecting the quiscent current (~4mA from graph in datasheet ==> 4*9 = 36mW) considering DPAK with thejaJ-A as 92 enter image description here

Vinmin =9V, Voutmax = 5.5V(USB), TA =25 (assumed), Tj=150(from datasheet) maximum current can give = (150-25)/(92)*(9-5.5) = 0.388A. AS we don't much info regarding current limit, and thermal shutdown point, also block diagram doesn't given any circuitry regarding current Limit, thermal shutdown, You can confirm these things from vendor.

There are very good application notes from different vendors regarding thermal analysis. http://www.ti.com/lit/an/slva118/slva118.pdf

I have seen sometimes people will take more current from LDO than rated, unless it will not exceed the thermal trip point, but most of the times it mostly transient current.

Last,

there is no chance of getting 500 mA from this regulator for your input(9V), Output(5V) combination.