Electronic – A simple voltage divider

troubleshootingvoltage divider

enter image description here

I attended a workshop on troubleshooting and we were asked to find the flaw in the given circuit. A guy pointed out to the organizer that R3 was short ckt and R2 was open ckt.

However I was pretty sure that R2 was short ckt and R3 was open ckt because same voltage is appearing, but didnt point out ( for which I lost a 1 minute clapping).

So who was correct (or no one ) ?

Thank you.

Best Answer

Actually you only need R3 to be an open circuit. Then no current is flowing in the other three resistors, hence the given readings. You could say that the others are shorts, but it's not required (or knowable given R3 as open).