I have a 5500/380V Dyn11 transformer, with possible tap settings of 0.95, 0.975, 1.00, 1.025 and 1.05 on both primary and secondary side.
Due to high loading, I want to change the tap settings to either 0.975/1.00, or 1.00/1.025. However, I'm not sure on what side of the transformer I should change the setting.
My intuition tells me that it makes more sense to select the primary side, but I'm not certain.
- One reason for changing the setting on the primary side is: The current is much higher on the secondary side, thus increasing the number of windings there will cause higher losses.
- Another one: More windings might lead to saturation (I would however think that the transformer was designed so that this won't be a problem).
Does the transformer type play a role? Does it matter if the transformer is Dy, Yd, Dd, Yy etc? How will it affect the impedance?
Will there be any side-effects of selecting one or the other? Are there any reasons for choosing to change the settings on the secondary side?
Thanks!
Best Answer
In Australia, at least, the tap-changer is always on the HV winding. I don't recall ever seeing a transformer with the tap-changer on the LV winding.
I believe this is for economic reasons (it's cheaper or easier to build it this way). However I haven't looked this up so treat the previous statement with a grain of salt. The J&P Transformer Book, originally my Martin Heathcote, is all about the details of design, construction, and maintenance of power transformers and could probably tell you more.
To give a more concrete example, here is an example of a transformer nameplate showing the possible tap positions. (Serial numbers have been obscured to protect the innocent.)
Note that the nominal voltage ratio is 11,000 / 440 V and five taps of 2.5% are provided, two taps up and two taps down.
You say your transformer has both HV tapchanger and LV tapchanger - is this a real, physical transformer, or a theoretical transformer? Having both HV and LV tap changer would be an extra expense and I am not sure if there would be any advantage to providing both.
A quick skim of J&P Transformer Book (12e) ยง2.4 mentions that HV tap-changers imply operation at "constant flux density", while LV tap-changers imply operation at "variable flux density".