Electronic – Do all components obey Kirchhoff’s Current Law

chargecurrentkirchhoffs-laws

Kirchhoff's Current Law states that the net current through a node is always 0. AFAIK this derives from conservation of charge principle. My question is, is KCL applicable to any electrical component? For example is it applicable to transistors, integrated circuits, etc.

My thought is that it should be applicable, because otherwise, the component would be accumulating charge over time, which I presume is not a stable or desirable (in general) condition. Another possibility would be that the component would be "leaking charge". For example, the component would be "throwing charge into air" etc. In this case, the component is not accumulating charge but charge is being moved out of the circuit. I guess this doesn't happen in general as well.

So my question is, is Kirchhoff's Current Law is applicable to any circuit element? For example, if I add up the currents through pins of an integrated circuit at a given time by taking current directions into account, will I get 0 amperes? Similarly for any other circuit elements. Are there any cases where the net current is not 0 amperes?

Best Answer

You are exactly right: due to the conservation of charge, which is a direct consequence of the gauge symmetry of electrodynamics and therefore an unbreakable (according to all current knowledge) law of nature, the sum of current over all possible paths summed over all time is always exactly zero. In the case where the current doesn't go through discrete conductors, it's known as Gauss's Law.

For real life electronic components, Kirchoff's current law is exact to the accuracy that all the current flows through the devices pins. This is usually a very good approximation, since any imbalance in charge tends to get balanced due to electric attraction. Some components though, such as an electron gun, break this on purpose, and therefore from a circuit perspective explicitly break Kirchoff's law. Of course if you account for the stream of electrons coming out, the current law holds again.

Now there's a small but important caveat here: the charge only has to be conserved in the end, not at each moment of time separately. That means that if there's a component that stores net charge, the current can enter there, wait for some amount of time as a charge, and the exit only later. However, no practical component stores appreciable net charge for any appreciable amount of time. This is also true of capacitors and batteries: a capacitor stores an equal amount of positive and negative charge on its plates, whereas a battery has positively charged and negatively charged ions which flow (as electric current) to meet each other when the circuit is in operation. In both cases, the net charge is zero at all times, and so the total charge is constant, and Kirchoff's current law still holds. The same also holds for Flash memories, that is, the charge stored is balanced by a hole in the semiconductor.

However, as the The Photon points out in his answer, for components such as antennas, there may be a small but finite time delay between the current entering a component and exiting it.

Nonetheless, for all practical electronics purposes, for example a complicated IC as specifically mentioned by the OP, Kirchoff's current law holds exactly.