Electronic – Exceed recommended power supply range on analog switch

analog-switchtransistors

I would like to use an analog switch in my design (NLAS5223C).

The recommended power supply range is up to 4.5V, and the absolute maximum rating is up to 7.0V (relevant specs attached below.)

I'm wondering, if it safe to use this device with the power supply rail at 5V.

I'm sure the official response from On Semiconductor would be that I shouldn't use this device above 4.5V, but I'm wondering what is the effect/risk of exceeding this limit, especially in this particular case of 0.5V. I've also posed this question to On Semi – no response yet, but I'll update here if they do get back to me.

I'm also curious what's happening to the device internally, and if there's a way to quantify the effect / risk.

Note: I intend on passing analog signals from 0-5V through the device. This device does have internal ESD diodes, but I'm assuming that the clamping diodes are relative to the power supply rail, and therefore shouldn't impact the analog signal.

enter image description here

Best Answer

The obvious answer is no. That's what data sheets are for.

However, it's tantalising to have an absolute max above what you want to run it at, isn't it.

The fact that the analogue inputs give a voltage specification with respect to rail confirms that the protection diodes are to the rails.

A serious problem is hinted at by the fact the digital absolute max is not with respect to the rails, but to an absolute voltage of 5.5 V. This is still above 5 V, isn't it? But it's a lot closer than the 7 V for the rails, and suggests there are lower breakdown devices inside. The same applies to TTL, and there the recommendation is not to tie inputs to VCC.

If you're a professional, or intending to sell this stuff, then the answer still has to be an unequivocal no. If you're an amateur, making one, and its failure is not going to inconvenience you beyond making another, then why not try it? You'll probably get away with it. Its failure mode is unlikely to be bursting into flames.

If you're building it for a friend, then you're putting your reputation on the line, is that a thing worth risking? Don't post it either as a 'good' circuit, it isn't.

The manufacturer is rating this switch with their reputation in mind. They don't want to be known for 'fragile' products, so they will have built in some margin, which includes users sometimes having a bit of over-voltage on their rails. How much of that margin do you want to knowingly use up? You might want to put more effort into making sure the power supply doesn't spike. It would definitely be worth trimming a bit off the digital control voltage, or restricting its input current, as is the recommendation with TTL.

There are other analogue switches rated for the voltages you want, though this one has a rather nice low on channel resistance. Is that the reason for it? If so, consider designing with FETs, and you'll get even better on channel resistance, though at the expense of space and component count. Unfortunately, really low Ron often goes with low voltage, and a lot of designs today are targetted at single cell LiPo products, like phones.

Related Topic