Electronic – getting odd inductances from home made inductor

inductormeasurementplanar-inductor

This question is related my my previous question: What to do about very hot planar inductor?

What I'm trying to do

I am trying to make a planar inductor (made from the tracks of the PCB, and surrounded by a 2 part a ferrite core). According to the datasheet of the ferrite core, the AL value is 1700nH, which means that with 12 turns around the core, I should get 12x12x1.7 = 244uH.

The problem

However, when I measure the inductance on my LC meter, it reads only 1.8uH. What's stranger is that if I create an inductor with the same core, but using stranded wire, and only 10 turns, I get 46uH!

I measured the resistance of the PCB tracks, and it's 0.25R, just as it should be, so I don't think there's a short in there.

Planar vs wound inductor

Planar inductor layers

My questions

What's going on? Is the AL value not sufficient for calculating inductance? How could it be that fewer turns gives a much higher inductance? Is the stranded wire massively better than PCB trace?

Best Answer

Brian has nailed it. Good shout. @Brian please take this picture and make your own answer. I'll delete this answer as soon as: -

enter image description here

NO VOTES PLEASE