Electronic – Incorrect resonator/crystal PCB layout

crystalpcbresonatorschematics

Hobbyist developing first PCB. Only caught this on my PCB/Schematic design after I had received them, was too focused on functionality of other components.

Resonator designed like crystal, resonator GND pins not going to GND. How it's designed.

enter image description here

How it should be designed according to datasheet.

enter image description here

Edit: Ignore schematic title, its obviously a resonator.
Edit+: https://datasheet.lcsc.com/szlcsc/1811141821_Yangxing-Tech-X322516MLB4SI_C13738.pdf – Apologies, thought resonators all wired the same.
enter image description here
**Have I ruined my PCB? **

Thanks ๐Ÿ™‚

Best Answer

Well the two GND pins are probably there to bring casing and everything to a defined potential; thus, performance will be better when you connect them, but it might work without. Hard to tell.

However, this connection (for the low frequency of 16 MHz) doesn't need to be crazy good โ€“ a short, well-soldered wire that connects the two ground pins to the nearest ground contact should work.

Generally, unless you're doing really high-frequency things, or more than 2 layers, if in doubt, have a ground plane. If you have one, finding a place where to solder these might be really easy (you can even scratch off a bit of solder mask, apply flux and solder directly onto that.)

Related Topic