Electronic – limit to the number of inputs that can be summed with an op-amp summing circuit

noiseoperational-amplifiersumming

I'm interested in the limits you encounter if you try to add many inputs into an op amp summing circuit. I've read that the inverting configuration is more natural for adding many inputs since the gain for an input is just determined by the feedback resistor and the resistor on that particular branch. Is there a maximum number of inputs you can get away with?

This answer maximun number of inputs on a opamp adder circuit (dealing with a non-inverting amplifier) says that noise is a limiting factor as you add each input. I guess I would assume that the noise would add in quadrature so that the noise would go as sqrt(N) for N inputs. Is this right – and are there any other factors that would limit you from adding inputs indefinitely? Thanks!

Best Answer

A summing amplifier: -

enter image description here

A summing amplifier showing the internal noise source of the op-amp: -

enter image description here

Now let's show that circuit with all the summed inputs connected to ground: -

enter image description here

The noise gain of this circuit is: -

$$1 + \dfrac{R2}{R1/3}$$

So, as you add more inputs (more R1 resistors connected to ground) the R1/3 term becomes R1/4 (four inputs) then R1/5 for 5 inputs. This means that the output noise caused by the grounding of inputs gets bigger as you add more inputs.

But you might say that the inputs are connected to voltage sources and not grounded. And I would say it matters not one bit because whether inputs are connected to ground or a real voltage source then noise becomes progressively amplified as you add more inputs. Sure, an unconnected input won't add more noise gain.

But also, as you incorporate more summing inputs the non-inverting input node acquires more parasitic capacitance to ground and it eventually dominates the input resistors at high frequencies (hence why I've removed the input resistors): -

enter image description here

And the noise gain clearly becomes very massive at higher frequencies because Xc becomes very large.

are there any other factors that would limit you from adding inputs indefinitely?

  • The inability of the op-amp to provide the current to all the inputs and thus not maintain the virtual earth condition required for proper numerical summing.