Electronic – MOSFET delay time when transitioning between triode and saturation regions. Charging and discharging mosfet

mosfet

Summary
For a mosfet, transition from saturation to triode region happens much quicker than from triode to saturation. Why?

Details
UPDATE: the load resistor was removed.
enter image description here
Fig.1: Schematic

enter image description here
Fig.2 Transient analysis

Notes:
1) BSIM4 SPICE model of MOSFET is used. Model parameters used (file cmosedu_models.txt) can be downloaded here.

  • Initially, the transistor is in saturation region (Vgs=350mV > Vth=280mV, Vds=V(out)=400mV > Vdssat=50 mV). Idssat=10uA.
  • After Vgs has increased, the transistor moves into triode region and its Vds goes down from 400 mV to 8 mV (below Vdssat).
  • Then, the opposite transition happens.
  • Transistion from triode to saturation takes around 6 ns, while transition from saturation to triode happens almost instantaneously.Why such a difference?

Appendix
enter image description here
Fig.3: Transistor parameters (for the operating point corresponding to Vgs=350mV).
Source: CMOS Circuit Design, Layout, and Simulation, Third Edition. R.J. Baker. Page 300.

Best Answer

I'm going to post an answer but it's really adding more details to Mario's correct answer and, if he wants to strip my answer of anything I'll just delete this.

A randomly googled MOSFET output (DS) capacitance versus drain voltage: -

enter image description here

It doesn't matter what MOSFET you use, the drain capacitance (\$C_{OSS}\$) at 1V (as per Sergei's table in his question) will increase to something like 4 times that value when the MOSFET is fully on in the triode region. The drain voltage is 8 mV and, as you can see \$C_{OSS}\$ rises to about 20,000 compared to about 5000 at 1V.

It's all relative and these could be farads, pico farads or fractions of femto farads.

So if the drain capacitance is 6 fF at 1V then it is likely to be in the realm of 24 fF at about 8 mV drain voltage. At 450 mV (as per the waveform in the question), the capacitance could be about 12 fF.

If 24 fF is charged with 10 uA the dV/dt will be 10 uA / 24 fF which is 417 volts per us OR 417 mV per nano second. Here's what it will look like against Sergei's picture (orange is the line I've added spanning between 6 ns and 7 ns and rising from 0 mV to ~417 mV): -

enter image description here

Clearly it's about the same sort of rate as he is seeing and the exponential asymtotic shape is going to be due to non-infinite drain resistance.

It's going to be more complex than this because the \$C_{OSS}\$ falls rapidly as drain voltage rises and, if the equivalent drain saturation resistance were infinite (i.e. a tending towards a true flat line), I would expect more like an exponential rise rather than a linear or asymtotic rise.

Anyway, @Mario, strip out anything you want and let me know to delete my answer.