Electronic – Proximity sensor for height from snow covered ground

distanceproximity-sensorsensor

I will preface this by saying that I am a hobbyist not an engineer, which is probably why I even have to ask this question.

Like the title says I want to know what type of sensor I can use to get the height of an object from the snowpack covering the ground, not the ground itself.

It will be attached to an object in motion.

Some sensors I have looked up state that they go through snow in their descriptions, but I am unsure if they simply mean falling snow in the air or if the meant packed snow on the ground.

So far the options seem to be laser, radar, infrared, ultrasonic, and possibly optical.

An accuracy of inches would be preferable but feet would be ok. This rules out barometric pressure.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Best Answer

Some of the options mentioned in your question would work for the purpose, with varying precision and suitability:

  • Ultrasonic: Probably your best bet: Narrow aperture piezoelectric ultrasonic sensors (single-unit send/receive) are reliable in ranges from a few inches to a hundred feet or more. Cost goes up disproportionately with range, though. Precision is fair-to-high, and it works with most surfaces, including reflective and transparent ones i.e. packed snow or sheet ice. Scan frequency is fairly high.
    • Senix TSPC-21S series has a range precisely matching your requirement, 50 feet range / fractional inch interpolated precision, but costs around $500-800. Some Chinese clones do exist, at around a tenth the price or less, but no idea on precision or reliability. We had ordered one, it arrived badly damaged, seller was unresponsive. Maybe give it a try if you don't need it waterproof.

Senix narrow-aperture ultrasonic distance sensor

  • Laser: Pulsed time-of-flight principle, similar to ultrasonic sensors. Scanner type, since reflector type will not work with snow. Range up to 40 feet, precision extremely high.
    • SensoPart FT 90 ILA might suit the requirement if 30 feet range is acceptable. It claims 2 mm precision, which is meaningless for uneven snow surfaces.

SensoPart scanning laser distance sensor

The following would not be recommended:

  • Optical: These too use lasers, but operate on a stereoscopic triangulation principle. Range is limited, typically to 1 meter. Precision is very high, scan frequency is high.
  • Radar: Insufficient precision and insufficient minimum range. Integrated RADAR devices are usually for 10 feet minimum to several miles maximum range, weight is massive as range increases, and precision is in tens of feet.
  • Infrared: Insufficient maximum range for your purposes. Conventional IR reflectometry works up to a couple of feet at the most, and is more popular in sub-foot ranges. However, the Laser device listed above is also infrared, in that it uses an infrared scanning laser.

I hope this helps

Related Topic