Electronic – Question about Third order Butterworth Filter Design

circuit-designfilteringoperational-amplifier

I'm new to PSpice and filter design and I'm trying to design a third order Low pass Butterworth Filter with cut-off frequency = 10 Hz. Here is the circuit that I've designed:

enter image description here

I've applied a 5V sinusoid with 2V DC offset to check whether it is working or not. Here is the result that I'm obtaining:

enter image description here

At the output I should get 2V, which is exactly the DC component of the sinusoid that I want, correct? However, I have no idea why it is taking so long for the output to settle into 2V (~ 0.2 seconds). Is there any way I can improve this design in order to minimize this stabilization time? Furthermore, could someone provide me some recommendation on which OP AMP comercially available models it is best to use for filtering?

Thanks for your attention.

Best Answer

Your LPF with 10Hz cutoff has transient reponse that will take about 0.5s (about 5*1/fc) to fully settle. That's what you are seeing.

For faster step-response settling you need to pick a wider filter with higher Fc.

Have a look here for the relationship between rise time and filter Fc:

enter image description here

Image from https://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=9817

There are circuit tricks to get it to start at a desired known non-zero DC by initializing your filter to a desired "reset" state. Although this does not change the rise time, it does allow the circuit to start at a pre-fixed DC level immediately after a reset. (This requires additional analog switches and control circuitry)