Electronic – Recommended Mosfets for switching purposes

mosfet

I'm looking for common MOSFETs to do some experimenting with. They should be able to switch at least 3A at 15V, have a low on resistance for power efficiency and also be quite cheap.

I require all four types, that is P & N channel, both depletion and enhancement mode.

So far I've found the following enhancement mode MOSFETS:

I think these MOSFETs will do the job. However, I'm struggling to find comparable depletion mode MOSFETs. Can anybody make a recommendation?

In general, is there a preference between using a N channel or P channel for switching purposes? I understand with a P channel the source is connected to positive while with an N channel the source is connected to ground. Practically does this make a difference?

Best Answer

There is definitely a preference for switching with N-channel MOSFETs. There are two primary practical reasons:

  1. Electron mobility in silicon is ~2-3x higher than hole mobility. This means that, for a given \$BV_{DSS}\$ and \$R_{DS(ON)}\$, an N-mos will be half to a third of the size of a P-mos, and therefore half to a third of the price (raw silicon cost; this doesn't account for package cost, et al).
  2. N-channel MOSFETs switching high-voltage loads can have their gates driven by a signal that is close to ground, obviating the need for a level shifter. (After all, most control circuits are ground-referenced.) P-mos, on the other hand, require a high-side referenced control signal.

As for discrete depletion devices, those are fairly hard to come by. You'll have much better luck looking for JFETs.