Would a heating element have a very high resistance, or a very low resistance? (All comments in this post are based around the fact that the voltage is the same for each situation) I would have thought that a higher resistance would have resulted in more heat loss, but I've been taught that the higer the current, the more energy is lost to heat. Therefore, a lower resistance would release more heat.
Electronic – Resistance of a heating element
resistors
Related Solutions
Here is one way of understanding the problem and thus arriving at the solutions you seek:
- You have a voltage V applied across a "black box", consisting of a series of resistors R1, R2 and R3 in this case. The resistances are in series so they add up, thus the Black Box has a cumulative resistance of R = R1 + R2 + R3.
- A voltage applied across a resistance causes a current I to flow, thus: I = V / R.
- Since the constituent resistors are in series, the SAME amount of current must flow through each of them. There is no alternative path for current to flow from V+ to ground.
- A current across a resistance implies a voltage across said resistance, by the same formula as above, thus: V(r1) = I * R1. That is the potential difference between the two ends of resistor R1.
- Similarly, V(r2) = I * R2, and so on.
- Evidently, one of these resistors, R3, has one end at ground potential, i.e. 0 volts. Thus, the voltage from there to the other end of that resistor is V(r3). The voltage at the next higher measurement point is V(r3) + V(r2), since the voltages add up, and as stated above, reference to ground.
By following this process, the voltages at each of the points of any series resistance network can be computed if either the applied voltage V (15 volts in this case) or the flowing current due to it, is known.
Now, how does one decide what resistances to use? Well, make the total resistance too small, and the current will be high, potentially burning out the resistors or the power supply, or causing the supplied voltage to droop, depending on how ideal we are assuming things to be. Similarly, use too high a resistance, and too little current will flow, thus the readings will be swamped by other noise effects that exist in practical electronics from various causes.
So pick a number that you like, and divide it in the ratio you want the test-point voltages to be. The resistances need not be equal, just as the voltages need not be at 33% each - calculate for any ratio you want.
I hope this helped.
You could use a Polyimide etched-foil thin-film heater such as those made by Minco.
As far as refrigeration goes, if this was a serious high-volume application I'd be looking at something other than Peltier modules, probably completely out of the EE realm. Peltiers are just too inefficient and have too much thermal mass.
Related Topic
- Electronic – Choice of heating element (power resistor)
- Electronic – arduino – Best configuration for 400W resistive heating device
- Calculating Power and Setup using resistors as heating elements
- Electronic – Setting heat on electric stove
- Electronic – Building An Electric Kiln For Pottery
- Electronic – Controlling heat gun’s element: where to put SSR without disturbing motor
Best Answer
simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab
Figure 1. Does adding more resistors increase or decrease the total heat produced?
Therefore a lower the resistance value will result in more power dissipation or heat loss.
Mathematically this can be seen from the power equation \$ P = \frac {V^2}{R} \$ that, for a given voltage, power dissipated is inversely proportional to the resistance.
* A real power supply will, of course, have a limit to how much current it can produce before the voltage starts to droop.