Electronic – simple network analysis doesn’t give correct result

passive-networks

Well I tried to calculate the circuit below, because of little experience the calculation became terribly messy and I didn't solve it. I need to calculate the power given by the 3A current source.

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

First I summed the voltage & current sources. To a single voltage of 5V at the top and in the middle a source of 1.75A. Then I used superposition to calculate the voltage at the top (resulting in -2.5V)

schematic

simulate this circuit

I thought I could then simply say "this 1.75A source pushes current from 0V down to -2.5V so the power is \$P = -2.5V \cdot 3A = -7.5W \$
Simulation shows this is wrong, how would I calculate this problem? With nodal analysis?

Best Answer

To correctly apply superposition, you need to add the voltage due to the 1.75A current source in the right-hand circuit (which would be 1.75V) to the -2.5V due to the 5V voltage source in the left-hand circuit. The result is -0.75V, not -2.5V.

Related Topic