You should see immediately that the 7.09V can't be right. 7.09V on one end of the resistors and 12V on the other end can never give you 7V on the non-inverting input. Your equation for \$V_{REF}\$ seems to be wrong.
Here's how I do it. Since the current through the resistors is the same we have
\$ \begin{cases} \dfrac{V_{SAT+} - V_{UT}}{nR} = \dfrac{V_{UT} - V_{REF}}{R} \\ \\ \dfrac{V_{SAT-} - V_{LT}}{nR} = \dfrac{V_{LT} - V_{REF}}{R} \end{cases} \$
Filling in the parameters and eliminating R:
\$ \begin{cases} \dfrac{12V - 7V}{n} = 7V - V_{REF} \\ \\ \dfrac{0V - 6V}{n} = 6V - V_{REF} \end{cases} \$
From the second equation:
\$ V_{REF} = \dfrac{n + 1}{n} 6V \$
Replacing \$V_{REF}\$ in the other equation:
\$ \dfrac{12V - 7V}{n} = 7V - \dfrac{n + 1}{n} 6V \$
We find \$n =11\$, that's also the value you found. But my \$V_{REF}\$ is different:
\$ V_{REF} = \dfrac{n + 1}{n} 6V = 6.55V \$
This is OK for a theoretical calculation, but in practice you may have a problem: do you have a 6.55V source? The typical way to solve this is to get a reference voltage via a resistor divider from your 12V power supply, and then you get this circuit:
We still have 2 equations, but three unknowns, so we can choose 1. Let's pick a 30k\$\Omega\$ for R3. Then, applying KCL:
\$ \begin{cases} \dfrac{12V - V_{UT}}{R1} + \dfrac{V_{SAT+} - V_{UT}}{R3} = \dfrac{V_{UT}}{R2} \\ \\ \dfrac{12V - V_{LT}}{R1} + \dfrac{V_{SAT-} - V_{LT}}{R3} = \dfrac{V_{LT}}{R2} \end{cases} \$
Filling in our parameters:
\$ \begin{cases} \dfrac{12V - 7V}{R1} + \dfrac{12V - 7V}{30k\Omega} = \dfrac{7V}{R2} \\ \\ \dfrac{12V - 6V}{R1} + \dfrac{0V - 6V}{30k\Omega} = \dfrac{6V}{R2} \end{cases} \$
That's
\$ \begin{cases} \dfrac{5V}{R1} + \dfrac{5V}{30k\Omega} = \dfrac{7V}{R2} \\ \\ \dfrac{6V}{R1} - \dfrac{6V}{30k\Omega} = \dfrac{6V}{R2} \end{cases} \$
From which we find
\$ \begin{cases} R1 = 5k\Omega \\ R2 = 6k\Omega \end{cases} \$
The answer from discussion above:
"it was actually the internal pulldown despite the value not making sense. When I configured P1.5 as a comparator input, Grace greyed out the column to configure the pulldown so I figured it was not available when using the comparator alternate pin function. Turns out, if you go into the other tab to set up the registers manually (via checkboxes), the pulldown was still enabled in the register."
Best Answer
I generally first make an assumption about the state of the comparator (is it sinking, or is it high impedance) then do the derivations.
First assume the comparator is sinking. Because it's sinking, assume that pin 2 is at \$V_{EE} \$ potential. You may also assume that the comparator is able to sink enough current through \$R_{PULL-UP}\$ as to not allow it to source any current onto the R1-R2 net. The voltage at pin 10 becomes a simple voltage divider.
Next assume the comparator is high-impedance. Now you have a net with three resistors and two voltage sources (\$V_{REF}\$ and \$V_{PULL-UP}\$), since the comparator is (ideally) out of the equation now. Find the total current in the branch and calculate the voltage.