Electronic – the danger of using ground as the return path in normal use

groundgrounding

I watched a video in which a man showing how to save money by only spanning a single cable as follows.

enter image description here

The ac current passes through the single 30 meter long cable, a breaker, a lamp, and return via the ground.

What is the danger of this mechanism?

Best Answer

How well this works will depend heavily on the bulk resistivity of the soil and the ground rods used at each end.

National Electrical Code Sec. 250-54, requires that the resistance to ground of a buildings ground rod must be 25 ohms or less. If you attach a similar rod at the far end of your setup then the best you can guarantee is that the return path is less than 50 ohms, but how much less you can't know for sure without measuring.

If you use this setup you are effectively putting a series resistance of several 10s of ohms in series with your load. Worst case, if the ground impedance is 50 ohms then the maximum power you can transfer to the load is (120V)^2 / 100 ohms / 2 = 72W.

  • From an electrical standpoint, the main downside is not being able to deliver a lot of power.

  • From a legal liability standpoint, it might not meet building codes, which by itself is good enough reason not to do it.

  • From a safety standpoint, its at least possible to have proper grounding at both ends, since you need a ground rod at the far end.

  • From a cost standpoint installing the extra ground rod might cost more than just buying the extra wire.