Electronic – Use of choke to create analog ground: mistake

groundinginductor

Not infrequently I see designs that implement an analog ground like in the following schematic:

enter image description here

This is a breakout module that includes an electret microphone module and amplifier that could feed into the A/D converter of an arduino or similar. (It's Adafruit 1063, not to pick on them particularly, just an example).

The feature of interest is the choke FB1 in the ground line to create a separate "AGnd" Analog ground. I think the intent might be to run the Max4466 amplifier on a clean ground, separate from the noisy digital ground.

Now, it's certainly a good idea to separate AVCC from VCC with a choke, (as is done here with FB2), and bypass it with a cap to ground (not done here).

However, the choke in the ground conductor is a problem. The microphone and amp inputs are referenced to AVCC, but the amp output is referenced to the external ground. The consequence surely must be that half the noise on (external) VCC (JP1 pin 1) appears at the analog output (JP1-pin 3).

And indeed, this circuit produces very noisy output, when used, for example, with an Arduino and an SD card module as a sound recorder. (SD cards are latter notorious for VCC noise while writing.) This is greatly improved by replacing FB1 with a short, and adding better filtering in place of FB2.

My question:

In general, is there ever an argument in favor of putting chokes in the ground network to create ground branches that have some high-frequency isolation? My inclination is that grounds should always be as low-impedance as possible, with due regard to current flow issues, return paths etc to avoid unwanted voltage drops (star ground considerations etc), and not deliberately partitioned with chokes. But I've seen the addition of chokes to ground branches enough to wonder whether there is some argument in favor.

Best Answer

That's old practice.

PCB paritioning does not mean what you think it means. Partitioning means to separate components to different regions of the same single continuous ground plane so return currents of a noisy section don't flow under a sensitive section. Partioning components is better than splitting the ground plane (which is what your schematic is doing is called). It's really easy to make things worse by splitting than if you just did nothing in particular.