Electronic – Using Single-Phase and 3-Phase Equipment

single-phasethree phase

Let's say I have a single-phase facility and I plug in a piece of 3-phase equipment, what happens?

  1. Is it dangerous?
  2. Is it less efficient (if so, approximately how many percent less in efficiency)?
  3. What kind of adjustments, if any, would I have to make to make this setup work?
  4. Would it increase or decrease the number of amps I use compared to a piece of single-phase equipment?

Likewise, if I have a 3-phase facility and I plug in a piece of single-phase equipment, what happens?

  1. Is it dangerous?
  2. Is it less efficient (if so, approximately how many percent less in efficiency)?
  3. What kind of adjustments, if any, would I have to make to make this setup work?
  4. Would it increase or decrease the number of amps I use compared to a piece of 3-phase equipment?

The power company charges based on wattage, so how would I calculate to find out which setup would be most cost-effective?

Are there any basic ground rules that I should follow when trying to work out these relationships?

Best Answer

If you have a single-phase facility, you can't just plug in a piece of 3-phase equipment. You will need to find a way to adapt it for single-phase power. That will probably not be particularly easy and might not be possible at all. It could be done with no loss in efficiency and performance, but is more likely to be less efficient and not perform as well.

1A. If it can be adapted, that can be done safely.

2A. The efficiency reduction will probably be in the range of 0 to 15%.

3A. It is not a matter of adjustment, it a matter of changing the design in some way.

4A. The current increase will probably be in the range of 0 to 15%.

It is relatively easy to use single-phase equipment in a 3-phase facility. Three-phase facilities usually have some single-phase equipment connected. The only concern is that you should try to keep the overall usage balanced among the phases.

1B. Safety is not an issue.

2B The single phase equipment may be less efficient than equivalent 3-phase equipment by as much as 15%.

3B No adjustments will be required.

4B The current increase will be somewhat comparable to the efficiency decrease.

The basic ground rule and method for determining cost effectiveness is to list all the anticipated equipment required and get prices and specifications from the suppliers. Also get information from the utility that will supply the power and from installers.

Edit: You can not really make a good decision with out learning more specifics. The more specific information you put int your planning, the more likely you can make a good decision.