Electronic – Voltage Divider or Step-down transformer for voltage sensing 240V AC

mainstransformer

Hello I am trying to measure 240v mains AC as safely as possible. There seems to be 2 ways to do it, which of the two is better and preferred?

1. Voltage divider directly from the mains

I have found an schematic that seems to be form a data sheet of an adc where in the mains is directly voltage divided and connected to the adc

enter image description here

Rhi is 300k Ohm and Rlo is 750 ohm . I dont know why the 3 300kOhm are in series though. I do not know how to pick a appropriate varistor though i assume a 375 peak to peak voltage , would this be correct? Also is that earth or ground (adc ground) where neutral is connected because they sometime interchange the two and it becomes confusing in these situations.

  1. Voltage divider After a transformer

This approach seems to be the safer one but not a space saving one using a very small transformer like this that can output 5v and voltage divide from that

enter image description here

Is the ground necessary? I only added it because the other circuit added one.

My Thoughts

The reason i like number one is because it can be made much more compact than the second, I cannot decide if is it worth the protection of the entire circuit for a compact size. How likely is circuit 1 more to fail than circuit 2?

Best Answer

Don't use this circuit:

enter image description here

Why not?

  • It connects Neutral to ground, never do that! Although called "Neutral" there can still be a (dangerous) voltage on Neutral. Best case: the ground-fault-protector will trip and that will shut your mains off.

  • If you "solve" what I mention above by not connecting ground then your complete circuit could become mains live meaning you get an electric shock when you touch it and everything that is connected to it.

  • You cannot rely on the Live and Neutral to always be connected like that, in many countries Live and Neutral connections depend on how you plug in the mains socket. The UK style socket is the exception though. Then still, the socket could be wired in the wrong way.

So forget about this circuit.

Do use this circuit:

enter image description here

The transformer takes care of the mains isolation so the outputs of the circuit are safe to touch.

The ground connection isn't strictly needed, it is your choice to connect that ground to mains ground, a local ground (like a metal case) or just leave it unconnected.

Use a good quality transformer and reliability (chance that the circuit fails) should not be an issue.