The current from the relay opening doesn't go into the Vcc rail at all. It follows the path shown here:
The stored energy is dissipated in the diode drop and the coil resistance of the relay.
In the Zener diode configuration, the stored energy is dissipated in the full Zener voltage of the diode. V*I is a lot higher power, so the current will fall faster and the relay might open a little faster:
MOVs are different than Zeners, but fulfill a similar circuit function: They absorb energy when the voltage exceeds a certain level. They are used for overvoltage protection, not for precision things like voltage regulators.
Flogging the FREDs
Voltage fed converters with transformer isolation will exhibit ringing in the secondary. Ringing is caused by parasitic inductances and capacitances in the circuit, with the dominant elements will being the transformer leakage inductance (\$ L_ {\text {Lk}}\$) and junction capacitance ( \$ C_j\$)of the bridge diodes. The diode data sheet shows \$ C_j\$ of 32pF. I'm going to make a naive guess at \$ L_ {\text {Lk}}\$ of 500nH, but it will have to be measured to really know. So, an LC of 500nH and 32pF is what must be snubbed.
Spike amplitude without snubbing will be \$ 2 n V_ {\text {in}}\$, where \$ n \$ is transformer turns ratio and the factor of 2 is what you get for a high Q resonance.
There are different types of voltage snubbers; Clamping, Energy transfer resonant, and Dissipative. The clamping and resonant types require more parts and some involvement of active switches which I think make them impractical for this case. So, I am only going to cover dissipative snubbers because they are the most simple and work well with passive switches (like diodes or synchronous rectifiers).
The form of dissipative snubber that I will cover is a series RC placed in parallel with each bridge diode.
Some facts about RC dampening snubbers:
- They are all about impedance matching. You don't get to choose the snubber resistor value \$ R_d\$. The parasitic LC determines that for you by characteristic impedance Zo.
- You do get to choose the value of the snubber cap \$ C_d\$. That's important since the cap value sets the snubber loss (\$ P_ {\text {Rd}}\$)as \$ C_d F V^2\$ . Where V is the pedestal voltage and F is switching frequency. The snubber cap must provide a low impedance at the LC resonance of the parasitics, so it needs to be several times \$ C_j\$.
Some guidelines, and what to expect with RC dampening snubbers:
For \$ L_ {\text {Lk}}\$ of 500nH and \$ C_j\$ of 32pF, Zo will be 125Ohms. So, \$ R_d\$ would be 125 to match Zo. You may have to fine tune this a little since \$ C_j\$ is non-linear and falls off with reverse voltage.
Choosing the snubber cap \$ C_d\$ : Choose \$ 3 C_j\leq C_d\leq 10 C_j \$ . Higher values in the range do provide better dampening. For example, \$
C_d\$ of \$ 3 C_j\$ will result in a peak diode voltage of \$ 1.5 n V_ {\text
{in}}\$, while \$ C_d\$ of \$ 10 C_j\$ will result in a peak diode voltage of
\$ 1.2 n V_ {\text {in}}\$.
Dissipative snubber performance will not improve for \$ C_d\$ values
greater than \$ 10 C_j\$.
Power loss \$ P_ {\text {Rd}}\$, with a pedestal voltage of 1250V and F of 50KHz.
- If \$ C_d\$ is \$ 3 C_j\$ or 100pF, \$ P_ {\text {Rd}}\$ = \$ C_d F V^2\$ or 7.8W.
- If \$ C_d\$ is \$ 10 C_j\$ or 330pF, \$ P_ {\text {Rd}}\$ = \$ C_d F V^2\$ or 25.8W.
\$ C_d\$ of \$ 10 C_j\$ gives the best dampening with peak voltage of 1.2 time the pedestal voltage, but you can save some power with smaller snubbing caps if you can stand the higher peak voltage.
Best Answer
You can see my answer linked by DKNguyen about the real differences based on voltage. Realistically, for mains frequency normal applications you may as well buy 1N4007 or the SMT equivalents as the price difference is pretty small, at least for non-consumer quantities. In a million quantity the difference between a 1N4002 and an 1N4007 might be a total of $1,000, so it's worth spec'ing the cheaper one if it works and nobody wants to throw away a kilobuck.
The situation is rather different for Schottky diodes- higher rated voltage generally leads to a higher Vf at a given current. Compare the differences between 1N5817, 1N5818 and 1N5819 rated at 20, 30 or 40V.
Vf at 1A is max 0.45, 0.55 and 0.6V. So using a 1N5819 where a 1N5817 will do, means about 1/3 more power dissipation.