I am trying to clarify the difference between some current sensors, would i be correct in stating that Current Transformers induct the flux of collapsing magnetic fields caused by AC, but cannot sense DC, while hall effect sensors direct the magnetic field onto a semiconductor so they detect both AC and DC?
Hall effect vs Current Transformers as Current Sensors
currentsensor
Related Topic
- Hall Effect and Magnetoresistors
- Sensor – Difference Between Magnetic Field Sensor and Hall Effect Sensor
- Hall Effect Sensors – Is It Possible to Trace on a PCB?
- How to Design an AC Current Detection Switch
- Sensor – US5881 Hall Effect Sensor Not Detecting AC Field
- Electrical – Current Monitoring – CT vs Hall Effect vs Rogowski Coil
- Hall Effect Sensor – Using Hall Effect Sensor as a 2-Wire Switch
- Electronic – sensing current noninvasively using hall effect sensors
Best Answer
Yes, Hall effect sensors sense the magnetic field caused by current, and can therefore measure absolute current. A current transformer can only sense current down to some minimum frequency below which gain falls off rapidly. A current transformer can't sense a fixed current.
If you are measuring current of something that is inherently AC, like the power line, then a current transformer can be appropriate. If you really need to sense DC current, then you can't use a current transformer and a Hall effect sensor may be appropriate. Keep in mind that a Hall sensor requires separate power to operate.
The other major way to sense current is by using a sense resistor. The resulting voltage is not isolated, so that may need to be dealt with. In the case of a sense resistor, it is often convenient to put some detection and processing circuitry together with the sensor. That can the convert the result to digital and send the digital information over some isolation barrier, like a opto-coupler.