Why do different resistor values dissipate power at different rates in RL and RC circuits

capacitorinductorresistors

Physically what is happening here?

RL
My thoughts on this are that the inductor supplies a certain current, and current through a larger resistor dissipates more power.

RC
This one I'm not so sure about. I would say the same about voltage, but I think the current caused by this voltage will be proportional to the resistance values and so will the power dissipated by this. Somet

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab
The switch opens after being closed for a very long time.
hing isn't right conceptually, can someone help me clear this up?

Best Answer

but I think the current caused by this voltage will be proportional to the resistance values and so will the power dissipated by this

Let's work it out and see. We assume that the source is disconnected at t=0.

For RL and RC circuits with initial energy, i.e., there is an initial current through the inductor or an initial voltage across the capacitor, the current is given by:

\$i(t) = i_0 \ e^{-t/\tau} \$

For the RL circuit:

\$\tau = L/R, \ i_0 = i_L(0) \$

For the RC circuit:

\$\tau = RC, \ i_0 = v_C(0) / R \$

Now, let's calculate the power associated with the resistor R:

\$p_R(t) = i^2(t) R = i^2_0\ e^{-2t/\tau} \$

For the RL circuit:

\$p_R(t) = i^2_L(0)\ e^{-2t/\tau}\ R\$

As we expect for the RL circuit, the power is proportional to the resistance R.

For the RC circuit:

\$p_R(t) = \dfrac{v^2_C(0)}{R^2}\ e^{-2t/\tau}\ R = \dfrac{v^2_C(0)}{R}\ e^{-2t/\tau}\$

So, for the RC circuit, the power is inversely proportional to the resistance R.

How to intuit this without working through the math? Note that the larger the power, the sooner the initial energy is dissipated, i.e., the smaller the time constant.

Now, note the formula for the time constant. For the RL circuit, a larger R gives a smaller time constant while, for the RC circuit, a smaller R gives a smaller time constant.