Why is the gain of the amplifier not considered in the frequency calculations? (Sedra and Smith 6th edition, Example 1.5)

amplifiercircuit analysisfrequencygainsmith chart

In example 1.5 in Sedra & Smith 6th edition, the author's answer for item b) is 1 Mrad/s. To get this answer, the author considers the amplifier as a passive LP network and uses the time constant equation in table 1.2.

Image from book "Microelectronic Circuits", 6th Edition, Sedra & Smith, page 36
Copied from "Microelectronic Circuits", 6th Edition, Sedra & Smith, page 36.

My question is:

Why is the gain of the amplifier not considered in the frequency calculations? I mean, taking the magnitude of the transfer function, making it equal to unity and calculating for w, the result I obtained was 100 Mrad/s (due to 100 V/V gain of the amplifier).

What am I missing?

Best Answer

Why is the gain of the amplifier not considered in the frequency calculations?

In simplest terms, it's because they are looking for a relative value when they write "3-dB-frequency" (which means \$-3\:\text{dB}\$.)

Say \$V_o=\kappa\cdot V_s\$ (with \$\kappa\propto \mu\$.)

\$V_o\$ depends on both \$V_i\$ and \$\kappa\$.

\$V_i\$ doesn't depend on \$\kappa\$.

Since \$V_o\propto V_i\$ when \$V_i\$ is \$-3\:\text{dB}\$ down, then \$V_o\$ will also be \$-3\:\text{dB}\$ down.

The \$-3\:\text{dB}\$ point doesn't depend on \$\kappa\$ (which depends on \$\mu\$.)