Crontab -e on gentoo failing: “chown: Operation not permitted”

crongentoo

I can't run crontab -e as a regular user on a gentoo box I've got. Here's a transcript:

ben@tools ~ $ crontab -e
    # (I add something trivial, like a new line containing "#foo")
crontab: installing new crontab
chown: Operation not permitted
crontab: edits left in /tmp/crontab.XXXXULPy6M
ben@tools ~ $

I have another gentoo machine on which it works fine.

I've checked permissions on all these things, and they all look both sensible and identical to the machine where it works:

tools ~ # ls -AFlh /usr/bin/crontab 
-rwxr-s--x 1 root crontab 29K Oct 22 16:16 /usr/bin/crontab*
tools ~ # ls -AFlhd /tmp
drwxrwxrwt 17 root root 3.2K Oct 22 16:34 /tmp/
tools ~ # ls -AFlhd /var/spool/cron
drwxr-xr-x 4 cron root 4.0K Oct 22 16:07 /var/spool/cron/
tools ~ # ls -AFlhd /var/spool/cron/crontabs
drwx-wx--T 2 root crontab 4.0K Oct 22 16:16 /var/spool/cron/crontabs/

I am a member of the groups cron and crontab:

ben@tools ~ $ groups ben
cron crontab sysops

there is no /etc/cron.allow, and /etc/cron.deny is blank apart from comment lines.

I've tried updating the vixie-cron package, by doing:

emerge --sync
emerge -v vixie-cron # reinstall the current version, in case something is wrong
# add "sys-process/vixie-cron ~x86" to /etc/portage/package.keywords
emerge -v =vixie-cron-4.1-r11

No good.

I've tried running strace against it (both as myself with strace -Ff crontab -e and as root by running crontab -e as myself and then strace -FF -p foo as root), but I can't see anything more useful than the error message I've already got:

chown32("crontabs/tmp.XXXXI5Oi61", 0, -1) = -1 EPERM (Operation not permitted)
write(2, "chown: Operation not permitted\n", 31) = 31
close(4)                                = 0

I have of course googled for it, and every google result has talked about checking permissions on the same files/folders I've checked above.

Help! I'm out of ideas.

Best Answer

Why "drwx-wx--T 2 root crontab 4.0K Oct 22 16:16 /var/spool/cron/crontabs/" this does not have a read permission for the groups?

Either assign the read permission for this crontabs/ directory. I guess the crontab is run as ben:crontab and crontab/ does not have permission for any groups to read from crontabs/

or try 'chmod 4755 /usr/bin/crontab'. With this crontab should be run as root:crontab and crontabs/ has read/write access to root.

How to fix all of your crontab related woes/problems (Linux)

This is a community wiki, if you notice anything incorrect with this answer or have additional information then please edit it.

First, basic terminology:

cron(8) is the daemon that executes scheduled commands.
crontab(1) is the program used to modify user crontab(5) files.
crontab(5) is a per user file that contains instructions for cron(8).

Next, education about cron:

Every user on a system may have their own crontab file. The location of the root and user crontab files are system dependant but they are generally below /var/spool/cron.

There is a system-wide /etc/crontab file, the /etc/cron.d directory may contain crontab fragments which are also read and actioned by cron. Some Linux distributions (eg, Red Hat) also have /etc/cron.{hourly,daily,weekly,monthly} which are directories, scripts inside which will be executed every hour/day/week/month, with root privilege.

root can always use the crontab command; regular users may or may not be granted access. When you edit the crontab file with the command crontab -e and save it, crond checks it for basic validity but does not guarantee your crontab file is correctly formed. There is a file called cron.deny which will specify which users cannot use cron. The cron.deny file location is system dependent and can be deleted which will allow all users to use cron.

If the computer is not powered on or crond daemon is not running, and the date/time for a command to run has passed, crond will not catchup and run past queries.

crontab particulars, how to formulate a command:

A crontab command is represented by a single line. You cannot use \ to extend a command over multiple lines. The hash (#) sign represents a comment which means anything on that line is ignored by cron. Leading whitespace and blank lines are ignored.

Be VERY careful when using the percent (%) sign in your command. Unless they are escaped \% they are converted into newlines and everything after the first non-escaped % is passed to your command on stdin.

There are two formats for crontab files:

User crontabs

 # Example of job definition:
 # .---------------- minute (0 - 59)
 # |  .------------- hour (0 - 23)
 # |  |  .---------- day of month (1 - 31)
 # |  |  |  .------- month (1 - 12) OR jan,feb,mar,apr ...
 # |  |  |  |  .---- day of week (0 - 6) (Sunday=0 or 7)
 # |  |  |  |  |
 # *  *  *  *  *   command to be executed

System wide /etc/crontab and /etc/cron.d fragments

 # Example of job definition:
 # .---------------- minute (0 - 59)
 # |  .------------- hour (0 - 23)
 # |  |  .---------- day of month (1 - 31)
 # |  |  |  .------- month (1 - 12) OR jan,feb,mar,apr ...
 # |  |  |  |  .---- day of week (0 - 6) (Sunday=0 or 7)
 # |  |  |  |  |
 # *  *  *  *  * user-name  command to be executed

Notice that the latter requires a user-name. The command will be run as the named user.

The first 5 fields of the line represent the time(s) when the command should be run. You can use numbers or where applicable day/month names in the time specification.

The fields are separated by spaces or tabs.
A comma (,) is used to specify a list e.g 1,4,6,8 which means run at 1,4,6,8.
Ranges are specified with a dash (-) and may be combined with lists e.g. 1-3,9-12 which means between 1 and 3 then between 9 and 12.
The / character can be used to introduce a step e.g. 2/5 which means starting at 2 then every 5 (2,7,12,17,22...). They do not wrap past the end.
An asterisk (*) in a field signifies the entire range for that field (e.g. 0-59 for the minute field).
Ranges and steps can be combined e.g. */2 signifies starting at the minimum for the relevant field then every 2 e.g. 0 for minutes( 0,2...58), 1 for months (1,3 ... 11) etc.

Debugging cron commands

Check the mail!

By default cron will mail any output from the command to the user it is running the command as. If there is no output there will be no mail. If you want cron to send mail to a different account then you can set the MAILTO environment variable in the crontab file e.g.

MAILTO=user@somehost.tld
1 2 * * * /path/to/your/command

Capture the output yourself

You can redirect stdout and stderr to a file. The exact syntax for capturing output may vary depending on what shell cron is using. Here are two examples which save all output to a file at /tmp/mycommand.log:

1 2 * * * /path/to/your/command &>/tmp/mycommand.log
1 2 * * * /path/to/your/command >/tmp/mycommand.log 2>&1

Look at the logs

Cron logs its actions via syslog, which (depending on your setup) often go to /var/log/cron or /var/log/syslog.

If required you can filter the cron statements with e.g.

grep CRON /var/log/syslog

Now that we've gone over the basics of cron, where the files are and how to use them let's look at some common problems.

Check that cron is running

If cron isn't running then your commands won't be scheduled ...

ps -ef | grep cron | grep -v grep

should get you something like

root    1224   1  0 Nov16 ?    00:00:03 cron

root    2018   1  0 Nov14 ?    00:00:06 crond

If not restart it

/sbin/service cron start

/sbin/service crond start

There may be other methods; use what your distro provides.

cron runs your command in a restricted environment.

What environment variables are available is likely to be very limited. Typically, you'll only get a few variables defined, such as $LOGNAME, $HOME, and $PATH.

Of particular note is the PATH is restricted to /bin:/usr/bin. The vast majority of "my cron script doesn't work" problems are caused by this restrictive path. If your command is in a different location you can solve this in a couple of ways:

Provide the full path to your command.
```
 1 2 * * * /path/to/your/command
```

Provide a suitable PATH in the crontab file

 PATH=/bin:/usr/bin:/path/to/something/else
 1 2 * * * command

If your command requires other environment variables you can define them in the crontab file too.

cron runs your command with cwd == $HOME

Regardless of where the program you execute resides on the filesystem, the current working directory of the program when cron runs it will be the user's home directory. If you access files in your program, you'll need to take this into account if you use relative paths, or (preferably) just use fully-qualified paths everywhere, and save everyone a whole lot of confusion.

The last command in my crontab doesn't run

Cron generally requires that commands are terminated with a new line. Edit your crontab; go to the end of the line which contains the last command and insert a new line (press enter).

Check the crontab format

You can't use a user crontab formatted crontab for /etc/crontab or the fragments in /etc/cron.d and vice versa. A user formatted crontab does not include a username in the 6th position of a row, while a system formatted crontab includes the username and runs the command as that user.

I put a file in /etc/cron.{hourly,daily,weekly,monthly} and it doesn't run

Check that the filename doesn't have an extension see run-parts
Ensure the file has execute permissions.
Tell the system what to use when executing your script (eg. put #!/bin/sh at top)

Cron date related bugs

If your date is recently changed by a user or system update, timezone or other, then crontab will start behaving erratically and exhibit bizarre bugs, sometimes working, sometimes not. This is crontab's attempt to try to "do what you want" when the time changes out from underneath it. The "minute" field will become ineffective after the hour is changed. In this scenario, only asterisks would be accepted. Restart cron and try it again without connecting to the internet (so the date doesn't have a chance to reset to one of the time servers).

Percent signs, again

To emphasise the advice about percent signs, here's an example of what cron does with them:

# cron entry
* * * * * cat >$HOME/cron.out%foo%bar%baz

will create the ~/cron.out file containing the 3 lines

foo
bar
baz

This is particularly intrusive when using the date command. Be sure to escape the percent signs

* * * * * /path/to/command --day "$(date "+\%Y\%m\%d")"

How to use `sudo` in cron jobs

when running as a non-root user,

crontab -e

will open the user's crontab, while

sudo crontab -e

will open the root user's crontab. It's not recommended to run sudo commands in a cron job, so if you're trying to run a sudo command in a user's cron, try moving that command to root's cron and remove sudo from the command.