Docker – Pros and cons of using Windows containers instead of Linux containers for Docker

dockerwindows 10

I'm installing Docker for Windows (CE) on Windows 10 and the first screen asks me:

[  ] Use Windows containers instead of Linux containers (this can be changed after installation)

This seems an important decision, yet the Docker documentation, FAQ and Windows container tutorial provides no information about why I might choose one over the other.

It would be helpful to have an objective overview of the ramifications of this choice:

  • Will one option be faster than the other?
  • Does the decision affect usage of system resources (RAM, CPU)?
  • Can I run the same images on both types?
  • Is one more secure than the other?

Any other distinctions that might help me reach a conclusion would be very welcome.

Best Answer

You HAVE to use a windows host for windows containers, however you can use either a Linux host or a Windows host for Linux containers. Since April 2018 you can even run both in parallel.

Will one option be faster than the other?

No. faster at what?

Does the decision affect usage of system resources (RAM, CPU)?

Windows uses more resources than Linux - Windows Nano is as small as it gets

Can I run the same images on both types?

No. you can run .NET apps in mono containers but you cannot start a windows container on a Linux host and vice versa - it's not the same as virtualization

Is one more secure than the other?

Again - more secure at what? No. They both run native Docker so it's nothing like hyper-v vs VMware and more like Linux vs Windows so it all depends on what you are going to run .net, python, java, ruby etc.

Related Topic