Cloudflare – Using with .DE Domain

The only way to determine if a domain is available or not is to query the registry database for that domain. Usually you can do that by performing a WHOIS query on the registry WHOIS interface.

There are several reasons to explain why a DNS check is not safe.

The most simple explanation is because you can register a domain without pointing it to any location. It's like a house. You can buy a house, but you are not forced to build a road to reach it.

The most part of available domain providers force you to point a DNS, otherwise they set a default one. But you're not forced, it's not a kind of mandatory domain requirement.

The second reason is because there are actually cases when a domain is registered but not available. One of this cases is the period often known as redemption period. This period lasts for some days after the domain is expired and the current owner don't renew it. Several registries disable the domain, it means it is no longer reachable via DNS, but the domain still exists and can be redeemed (usually) only by the original owner.

The DNS check is cheap and sometimes faster. If you need to check whether the domain exists, then you can try a DNS query first and, in case of failure, fallback to the WHOIS query. In other words, if the DNS query succeed the WHOIS query is almost pointless. But you cannot do the opposite because if a DNS query fails, it doesn't mean the domain is not registered.

First, thanks a lot for using your actual hostname and information in the question, it helps a lot!

The 451 DNS temporary failure means that the recipient mail server is unable to resolve the hostname at that point in time. I've looked at your DNS records and I can't see anything strange about them that would cause this, so I'd say that the problem is with the CloudFlare DNS servers. It may be that there is some firewall or rate limiting or some other issue that means they either don't respond or don't respond quickly enough for the mail servers to get the information they want in order to accept the emails.

You can contact the postmaster at the recipient site (in theory, the address "postmaster@theirdomain.com" should both work and be read by a human being, but we all know the difference between theory and practice!) and ask them if they can see why the checks failed. I'd also check with the CloudFlare support staff if they've seen the same problems for other customers.