Mix ECC RDIMMs with different rank

ecchardwareintelxeon

I have an Intel S5520SC motherboard with two Intel Xeon E5620 CPUs installed. It currently has six KVR13R9D4/8I DIMMS – I want to add another six DIMMs (48GB of RAM) to upgrade this workstation to 96GB of RAM. Unfortunately, Kingston has discontinued those DIMMs. My supplier is telling me that KVR16R11S4/8I will work, but I'd just like to check before spending money on this.

Both DIMMS are 8GB, 1.5V power supply, ECC, registered, have 8 banks and use 4-bits per RAM chip. The differences are that the old RAM is 1333MHz and dual rank while the new RAM is 1600MHz and single rank. I don't see anything in the manual for the S5520SC that says mixing dual and single rank ECC RAM is allowed or not allowed.

Do I just have to make sure I don't mix single and dual rank DIMMs in the same channel? Should one CPU use the old RAM and the other the new RAM? Please advise. Thanks in advance.

Best Answer

It did work, and it seems to be stable too. I now have six KVR13R9D4/8I DIMMs and six KVR16R11S4/8I DIMMs plugged into the same S5520SC motherboard. The KVR16R11S4/8I DIMMs were plugged into the second slot of each channel. The KVR13R9D4/8I DIMMs were already in the first slot of each of the six channels. One possible hint that this would have worked is that Kingston markets KVR16R11S4/8I as the replacement for KVR13R9D4/8I.