Windows – Active Directory w/ no DC at small remote offices

active-directorynetworkingwindowswindows-server-2012-r2

I am new to Active Directory and I need to implement AD for an organization that has two larger locations and 5 smaller locations, all connected via an MPLS network. Here is a simplified diagram of the network:

Diagram

The main reason for implementing AD here is central authentication & user maintenance (and possible group policies). No roaming profiles, no Exchange, no file shares or other resource sharing.

The remote locations (C-G) have no servers and given the small number of workstations in these sites and their limited use of AD, I really do not want to install DCs with related infrastructure, cost & administrative overhead in those locations.

I plan to only use one domain, but have not yet decided on OUs, etc. (but overall I am trying to keep things simple).

Questions:

  1. Are T1s sufficient for this use of AD (the 5 stations at each location will typically only login 1-2 times / day)? Or is it likely to be very slow to login & bog down the T1s?
  2. Can I use only one site (despite the current 3Mbps link @ site B [to become a 10 Mbps in ~2 months])? If not, how about putting both DCs @ Site A?
  3. Other design recommendations for this scenario (remember, I am an AD noob)?

Best Answer

AD authentication requires very little bandwidth, especially if you aren't going to be sharing files over the network. At my company, we have 20-some retail stores with POS stations running Windows 7, and they connect to our main office with DSL lines, most of which are 3 Mb/s down and 768 Kb/s up. They have absolutely no issues with domain authentication, and we even push Windows updates via WSUS over those lines. I don't anticipate you would have any problems at all with having a DC at only one location.